Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
This is a highly operational, well-gated workflow: every phase has executable commands, explicit validation checkpoints, and error-recovery loops, and conditional branches state their activation conditions precisely. Its weaknesses are repetition of the enforcement mandates, a ~130-line bash script inlined where a bundled script should be, and no use of bundle files to keep SKILL.md closer to an overview. Tightening the repeated mandates and moving the persistence script and audit question sets into scripts/ and references/ files would improve both conciseness and progressive disclosure.
Suggestions
Move the Step 8 persistence logic into a bundled script (e.g., scripts/persist-design.sh) and invoke it with the design body, cutting ~130 lines from SKILL.md and fixing the largest progressive-disclosure gap.
State the "minimum 3 search.py calls" requirement once (in the HARD-GATE or Step 4) and remove the duplicated mandate from the enforced-mode preamble and step headers.
Extract the Step 7b AI Surface Audit questions and the Step 1 question sets into a references/ file, keeping only the summary and pointer inline, so SKILL.md reads as an overview with one-level-deep references.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly dense, actionable instruction with no basic-concept padding, but it repeats the "at least 3 search.py calls" mandate three times (the HARD-GATE block, the enforced-mode paragraph, and Step 4's "This is NOT optional") and inlines a ~130-line defensive bash persistence script in Step 8. This fits "mostly efficient but could be tightened" — it is not 2 because there is no concept explanation Claude already knows, and not 4 because the repeated mandates and the inlined script exceed minor over-explanation. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Nearly every step ships copy-paste-ready material: exact bash with "${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT:-...}" fallback chains, seven concrete search.py invocations per domain, the full critique prompt, and the contrast-check.py call with argument format ("'<text-hex>:<bg-hex>' ... ':large'"). It falls short of 5 because Step 4b says "Dispatch to different providers for maximum diversity" without the actual dispatch command (unlike Step 5b's orchestrate.sh spawn), and Step 5's direction document format is left abstract ("Write the design direction as a structured section"). | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 1-8 are explicitly sequenced with blocking gates, conditional branches carry clear activation/skip conditions ("When fewer than 3 providers are available, skip to Step 5"), and validation is explicit with feedback loops: preflight terminates on MISSING_SEARCH_PY/MISSING_PYTHON, "Exit 1 means at least one pair fails WCAG AA — fix the palette and re-run before delivering", and the critique step mandates triage, revision, and a displayed diff. This matches the anchor for clear sequence with explicit validation and error-recovery loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Step headers are clear, but no bundle files exist (no references/, scripts/, or assets/), and substantial content that belongs in separate files is inlined: the ~130-line persistence script (Step 8) should be a bundled script, and the ~45-line AI Surface Audit (Step 7b) and the full question sets belong in reference files. References to skills/blocks/design-taste.md and vendored search.py are clearly signaled but point outside this skill's bundle. This fits "some structure but content that should be separate is inline" — not 4, because the inlined script and absent bundle structure are more than minor organization gaps. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |