Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers exceptionally concrete, executable guidance with a well-sequenced eval-and-iterate workflow and a genuine feedback loop. Its weaknesses are conversational padding and duplicate statements of the core loop, and — more seriously — references to files (agents/*.md, eval-viewer/generate_review.py) that are missing from the bundle, which undermines both navigation and the workflow steps that depend on them.
Suggestions
Ship the missing referenced files (agents/grader.md, agents/comparator.md, agents/analyzer.md, agents/openai.yaml, eval-viewer/generate_review.py) or rewrite the workflow steps to not depend on them — the grade/aggregate/viewer steps currently point to nonexistent paths.
Trim the chatty asides and remove the duplicated core-loop summary at the end; the body exceeds its own 500-line guidance largely due to filler and repetition.
Move the long Description Optimization details into a reference file, and add a table of contents to references/schemas.md (431 lines) as the skill's own guidance requires.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly efficient, concrete instruction, but contains noticeable padding: chatty asides ('Cool? Cool.', the plumbers-and-grandparents riff, 'we are trying to create billions a year in economic value here!', 'Sorry in advance but I'm gonna go all caps here'), and the core loop is stated twice ('Repeating one more time the core loop here for emphasis'). It does not reach the score-2 anchor's 'several unnecessary explanations' of concepts Claude already knows, but the redundant repetition and conversational filler go beyond the score-4 anchor's 'minor instances of over-explanation'. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | The guidance is copy-paste ready throughout: exact subagent task prompts, exact commands ('python -m scripts.aggregate_benchmark <workspace>/iteration-N --skill-name <name>', the full run_loop invocation with flags), concrete JSON templates for evals.json/eval_metadata.json/timing.json/feedback.json, and precise field-name requirements ('text', 'passed', 'evidence'). This matches the score-5 anchor (fully executable, covers common cases); the score-4 anchor's 'minor gaps' does not apply. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The eval workflow is a clearly numbered 5-step sequence with checkpoints (grade → aggregate → analyst pass → viewer → user feedback) and an explicit improvement loop with stop criteria ('The user says they're happy', 'feedback is all empty'). It falls short of the score-5 anchor because key steps depend on files absent from the bundle ('agents/grader.md', 'eval-viewer/generate_review.py'), leaving a gap in executing the validate/grade feedback loop as written. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Structure is present — references are signaled with when-to-read guidance ('See references/schemas.md for the full schema', 'Read agents/grader.md...') and are one level deep — but the body cites five files that do not exist in the bundle (agents/grader.md, agents/comparator.md, agents/analyzer.md, agents/openai.yaml, eval-viewer/generate_review.py), so navigation breaks at exactly the points the workflow depends on. Additionally, the ~535-line body exceeds the skill's own <500-line guidance with the long Description Optimization section inlined, and references/schemas.md (431 lines) lacks the table of contents the skill itself prescribes for >300-line references. This sits between the score-3 and score-4 anchors: better organized than score 3, but the broken references are more than the 'minor organization gaps' of score 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |