Content
55%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-written redirect stub: admirably lean, with genuinely useful cross-agent portability rules. But as a SKILL.md it contains none of the skill's actual instructions — everything is delegated to a relative path outside the bundle that does not exist here, leaving no task workflow and no resolvable references.
Suggestions
Make the skill self-contained: inline the core procedure, or move the source instructions into a references/ file inside the skill directory, instead of pointing to `../../../.claude/skills/coauthor-brief/SKILL.md`, which only resolves in the original repo layout and breaks when the skill is synced or reviewed standalone.
Add the brief-generation workflow to the body with sequenced steps (collect git delta since last brief, assess each artifact, compile open questions, write repro and restricted-data sections) and at least one validation checkpoint, e.g. verify the delta against `git log` output before writing the summary.
Keep the cross-agent adaptation notes, but place them under an explicit heading (e.g. '## Running from another agent') and give one concrete example of $ARGUMENTS substitution so the redirect plus rules is fully actionable on its own.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~25-line body is lean and imperative with zero concept explanations: it assumes competence ('Read that file now and follow it', 'Read the agent's file for what the step checks') and every bullet earns its place as a cross-agent portability rule. It matches the anchor 'lean and efficient; assumes Claude's competence; every token earns its place' rather than score 4's 'minor instances of over-explanation'. | 5 / 5 |
Actionability | The portability rules are concrete and executable — 'Where it says `$ARGUMENTS`, use what the user asked for', 'mark every result it produced *not independently verified*', 'repeat that check in Claude Code (`/verify-claims` for citations)' — but the actual task procedure (how to generate the brief: git delta, artifact states, repro steps) is entirely absent from the body, delegated to an external file. This fits the score-3 anchor 'some concrete guidance but incomplete; missing key details' rather than score 4, whose guidance is self-sufficient. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The only sequence present is a reading order ('Read [`AGENTS.md`] first if you have not already', then read the source SKILL.md); the multi-step workflow the skill exists for (gathering the git delta, per-artifact state, open questions, reproduction instructions, restricted-data steps) has no steps, checkpoints, or validation in the body. This matches anchor 2, 'rough sequence present but many gaps; steps poorly defined; validation absent', rather than anchor 3, which requires the actual task steps to be listed. | 2 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle contains only SKILL.md — no references/, scripts/, or assets/ — and the sole substantive reference points outside the skill directory to `../../../.claude/skills/coauthor-brief/SKILL.md`, which does not resolve in this environment, with 'the files it points to' implying further indirection. Navigation dead-ends at a broken external path, fitting the 'minimal structure / references effectively unusable' territory of anchor 2; it is not anchor 3, whose references at least resolve and merely lack clear signaling. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |