Conciseness

The body is efficient and adds mostly repo-specific knowledge Claude lacks ('NEVER force-push to main/master', 'Prefer `enh` for incremental improvements (common in this repo)'), but includes minor over-explanation of known concepts such as the HEREDOC code block and 'Before committing, count characters in the full subject.'

Actionability

Fully executable guidance throughout: concrete commands ('git log --oneline -30', 'pnpm lint:fix', 'pnpm check:push'), a copy-paste HEREDOC commit snippet, an exact message template '<type>(<scope>): <description>' with enumerated types/scopes, and six realistic example subjects covering the common cases.

Workflow Clarity

The Procedure is a clearly sequenced 7-step list with explicit validation ('Run `git status` after the last commit to verify success') and an error-recovery feedback loop ('run `pnpm check:push` ... and fix failures before suggesting `git push`'), plus parallelized setup steps and safety preconditions.

Progressive Disclosure

A well-sectioned single-file skill with no nested references and clearly signaled cross-links (e.g. '[check-push/SKILL.md](../check-push/SKILL.md)'), but at ~100 lines the repo-specific 'Backlog cull' subsection could plausibly live in a separate reference file; no bundle files exist to split into.

Specificity

It lists several concrete actions — 'Create scoped git commits from the current conversation', 'Splits logical changes', 'never blind full-folder commits' — comparable to the anchor-4 example, though coverage has minor gaps (no mention of message drafting or verification).

Completeness

It explicitly answers both: what ('Create scoped git commits ... Splits logical changes, never blind full-folder commits') and when ('Use when the user says /commit or asks to commit session work') with concrete trigger phrases, matching the anchor-5 exemplar structure.

Trigger Term Quality

Good natural keyword coverage — '/commit', 'commit', 'commit session work', 'git commits' — matching anchor 4; a few natural variants like 'commit my changes' or 'make a commit' are missing, so not 5.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

The commit-creation niche has distinct triggers ('/commit', 'commit session work'), but there is minor overlap risk with closely related git workflow skills (e.g. the check-push skill the body references), so anchor 4 rather than 5.