Conciseness

Nearly every token is repo-specific routing and narration guidance Claude cannot infer (persona statuses, field semantics, honest-gap rules), with no explanations of known concepts. Minor redundancy between the Step 3 bullets and the Output Format table glosses keeps it just below anchor 5.

Actionability

Provides a copy-paste-ready bash invocation with exact flags (--query, --no-api, --time-budget, --experience), the exact JSON fields to read and narrate, and named reference files per step. Fully executable with no pseudocode.

Workflow Clarity

Five steps are clearly sequenced (capture goal, run recommender, narrate, setup path, learning loop) with explicit validation of recommender output via routing_diagnostics and an error-recovery loop ('ask the user to rephrase; never present the beginner fallback as an exact intent match').

Progressive Disclosure

The body stays an overview and delegates details via a Resources section whose entries (scripts/recommend.py, references/intent_routing.md, references/setup_paths.md, assets/metadata_snapshot.json) all exist as real files, are one level deep, and each carry a one-line purpose statement.

Specificity

Enumerates multiple concrete deliverables ('trading workflow, skillset, API profile, and setup path') in third-person voice, plus explicit boundaries ('Routes and explains only; it never executes trades or auto-runs other skills, and it is honest when no workflow has shipped yet'). Comprehensive coverage of what the skill does; anchor 4 would require notable gaps, and there are none.

Completeness

Explicitly answers what ('Recommend the right trading workflow, skillset, API profile, and setup path from a natural-language goal') and when ('Use this as the on-ramp when a user expresses a trading or investing goal and needs to know which skill/workflow to use...') with concrete trigger phrases. Both are clear and explicit, matching the top anchor.

Trigger Term Quality

Quotes literal natural-language phrases users would say ('where do I start', 'which skill should I use', 'I want to swing trade only when the market is favorable', 'what works without API keys') including bilingual Japanese synonyms ('どれを使えばいい', 'API キー無しで使えるものは'). Coverage matches the comprehensive anchor.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

A clear router niche with a negative boundary ('never executes trades or auto-runs other skills') that separates it from execution skills. However, persona trigger quotes like 'I want to swing trade only when the market is favorable' would plausibly also match the skill-level trading skills it routes to, so minor overlap risk with closely related skills remains — anchor 4, not 5.