Conciseness

The body is mostly efficient and packed with domain-specific detail Claude would not know (warning penalties, EMA(3) smoothing, 10v10 acceleration window), but the '7-Level Zone Detail' table largely restates the 'Scoring Zones' table and the English/Japanese 'When to Use' block re-lists triggers already in the description; not a 1 because the bulk is genuinely non-obvious domain content rather than generic explanation Claude already knows.

Actionability

Provides a copy-paste-ready executable command ('python3 skills/uptrend-analyzer/scripts/uptrend_analyzer.py') plus a concrete numbered list of what the script does, matching the fully-executable anchor; not a 2 because it is a real runnable command rather than pseudocode or vague direction.

Workflow Clarity

The two phases (Phase 1: Execute Python Script, Phase 2: Present Results) are clearly sequenced with an explicit sub-step list and a defined presentation checklist (composite score, exposure guidance, sector heatmap, momentum/rotation signals); not a 2 because the sequence is unambiguous, and this is a read-only analysis flow so the destructive-operation validation cap does not apply.

Progressive Disclosure

SKILL.md stays an overview and signals a single one-level-deep reference ('references/uptrend_methodology.md', a real file) with explicit load guidance ('First use: Load uptrend_methodology.md'), keeping methodology detail off the main page; not a 2 because navigation is clearly signaled and the split is appropriate rather than an inline wall of text.

Specificity

Lists multiple concrete actions — 'Analyzes market breadth', 'diagnose the current market environment', 'Generates a 0-100 composite score from 5 components (breadth, sector participation, rotation, momentum, historical context)' — matching the anchor for listing several specific concrete actions; not a 2 because it goes beyond naming a domain to enumerating what it actually does.

Completeness

Explicitly answers both what ('Analyzes market breadth... Generates a 0-100 composite score') and when ('Use when asking about market breadth, uptrend ratios...'), matching the anchor for clearly answering both with an explicit 'Use when' trigger; not a 2 because the when clause is explicit, not merely implied.

Trigger Term Quality

'Use when asking about market breadth, uptrend ratios, or whether the market environment supports equity exposure' covers natural terms a user would say ('market breadth', 'uptrend ratios', 'market environment', 'equity exposure'); not a 2 because it gives several common phrasings rather than a single keyword.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

'Monty's Uptrend Ratio Dashboard' names a distinct, niche data source with dedicated triggers, making conflict with other skills unlikely; not a 2 because the named dashboard and breadth-participation framing carve out a clear niche rather than overlapping with generic analysis skills.