Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A dense, token-efficient overview with concrete commands, explicit binding-semantics rules, and a clear approval gate — genuinely actionable instruction-only guidance. Its weaknesses are over-compressed sentences that cost clarity, no example invocation or sample record, validation via "check" never wired into a workflow step, and references to five bundle files that do not exist in the bundle.
Suggestions
Add the referenced files to the bundle (workflows/create-decision.md, workflows/update-decision.md, schemas/decision-format.md, templates/decision-entry.md, templates/index-row.md) or inline minimal versions, since the body's navigation chain currently dead-ends at five missing paths.
Decompress the status-semantics rules (e.g. the removed-record rationale sentence) into a short status → binding-effect table; the current prose is token-efficient but requires multiple reads.
Include one example CLI invocation (e.g. a sample search and its output shape) and add an explicit step to run "decisions check" after creating or updating a record so validation is part of the workflow.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is highly lean — it never explains what an ADR is, assumes competence throughout, and packs every sentence with project-specific rules — but several sentences are compressed to the point of needing re-reads (e.g. "A removed record's reason lives where its Rationale cell names it, the comment at the code or the principle doc's section"), and removal/withdrawal rules appear in both the "A record is short" paragraph and the workflow triggers. Brevity that does not fully preserve clarity fits the 4 anchor rather than the 5. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete: an exact CLI invocation (".agents/skills/decider/scripts/decisions <command> [options]"), named actions ("search, search --issue, list, next-id, get, check"), named environment variables, explicit workflow paths, and an exact approval phrasing to say to the user. It stops short of the 5 anchor because no example command invocation (e.g. a sample search) or inline sample record is given — the worked example is delegated to another skill's file and to --help. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The reading sequence is explicit ("Read a hit's INDEX row first. Read an active or superseded record's document before treating it as binding"), the trigger-to-workflow table clearly routes create/update paths, and the approval gate is an explicit checkpoint ("Never create a decision document without explicit user approval"). The 5 anchor is not reached because the "check" action is listed but never prescribed as a validation step after create/update, and the actual step sequences are delegated to workflow files. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The SKILL.md itself is a well-organized ~50-line overview delegating detail to "decisions --help" and clearly signaled one-level references, which would merit a 4-5 — but the referenced bundle files (workflows/create-decision.md, workflows/update-decision.md, schemas/decision-format.md, templates/decision-entry.md, templates/index-row.md) are absent from the actual bundle, which contains only scripts/decisions and scripts/lib/kendex-env.sh. Scoring against the real bundle structure, the broken reference chain leaves navigation incomplete, fitting the 3 anchor better than the 4 ("minor organization gaps"). | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |