Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An operationally rich, highly actionable workflow with genuinely strong validation checkpoints, empirical justifications, and failure-mode handling. Its main costs are length-driven: duplicated prompt templates, a large inlined whitelist spec that belongs in a reference file, and disordered step numbering (duplicate Step 9s, 5.5 before 5b) that slightly muddies an otherwise clear sequence.
Suggestions
Factor the ~50-line reviewer prompt template out of Steps 2 and 5: state it once (e.g. in a shared reference or a single 'Reviewer prompt template' section) and have Step 5 reference it plus the fresh-context preamble — this removes the largest duplication and roughly 50 lines.
Move the edit-whitelist specification (schema, resolution rules, glob semantics, ~105 lines) into a dedicated reference file (e.g. references/edit-whitelist.md), keeping only the parameter definition, default-OFF note, and a pointer in SKILL.md.
Fix step numbering: rename the second 'Step 9: Summary' (and reconcile 'Step 9: Document Results'), and reorder so Step 5b (Human Checkpoint, which follows the Round 2 review) is not listed after Step 5.5 (Kill Argument) — or renumber the interleaved checkpoints (2b, 4.5, 5.5, 5b) into a consistent scheme.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~50-line reviewer prompt template is duplicated nearly verbatim in Steps 2 and 5, and the ~105-line edit-whitelist specification (schema, glob semantics, resolution rules) is fully inlined — both clear tightening targets. It stays at 3 rather than 2 because the material is dense operational knowledge (calibration rules, overfull thresholds, empirical motivations), not padded explanation of things Claude already knows. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides executable bash (latexmk/pdfinfo/grep pipelines), a concrete YAML whitelist schema, a regex detector table, and exact reviewer prompt templates. Below 5 because the Step 4.5 regression-check Python block is a skeleton whose core comparison is a comment ("# Compare normalized theorem blocks...") and prompts carry unfilled [VENUE]/[list figure files] placeholders. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 0–9 are clearly sequenced with strong explicit validation ("Verify: 0 undefined references, 0 undefined citations", the restatement regression test, hard-block stop criteria, an auto-fix pattern table) and recovery loops. Held below 5 by numbering incoherence: two distinct 'Step 9' headings and a confusing order where Step 5.5 (Kill Argument) precedes Step 5b (Human Checkpoint). | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Section headers are consistent and the three external shared-references links (reviewer-backends.md, writing-principles.md, review-tracing.md) are clearly signaled, but no bundle files exist to carry the load — the whitelist spec and the two duplicated reviewer prompt templates are exactly the kind of content that clearly belongs in separate reference files yet is inlined in SKILL.md. More than the 'minor organization gaps' of anchor 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |