Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a highly actionable, well-sequenced workflow for a genuinely complex task: nearly every step has executable commands, explicit validation gates, or concrete output specs, and the venue-specific rules are exactly the kind of detail Claude cannot infer. Its weaknesses are redundancy (duplicated watch-word lists, clarity rules, and prose-contract restatements) and a monolithic structure where the detailed writing-quality material belongs in the reference files it already points to.
Suggestions
Deduplicate the writing-quality guidance: the sentence-level clarity rules and AI watch-word lists each appear twice (Step 5 passes and again in the trailing 'Writing Quality Reference' section) — keep one copy and point to writing-principles.md for the rest.
Move the 12-rule 'CONFIDENT PROSE, HONEST LIMITS' block and the five detailed audit passes into a reference file (e.g., writing-principles.md or a new quality-pass reference), keeping SKILL.md as an overview that states the contract and links out.
Replace the comment-only 'Automated bib cleaning' pseudocode block with an executable script in scripts/ (the citation-filtering task it describes is fully mechanizable), or with real Python inline.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The bulk is genuinely non-obvious domain guidance (venue-specific preambles, IEEE page-limit rules, the DBLP/CrossRef fetch chain), but several sections are duplicated: the AI watch words appear in Step 5 ("Replace: delve, pivotal, landscape, tapestry, underscore") and again in the trailing "De-AI patterns" section, the sentence-clarity rules are listed twice within Step 5, and the 12-rule "CONFIDENT PROSE, HONEST LIMITS" block is restated in two Key Rules bullets. This is 'mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation or could be tightened' rather than clearly verbose. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable guidance dominates: copy-paste curl commands for DBLP/CrossRef ("curl -s \"https://dblp.org/rec/{key}.bib\""), venue-specific LaTeX preambles, a ready spawn_agent message block, and an explicit project file tree. Not 5 because the "Automated bib cleaning" Python block is comment-only pseudocode with no executable code, which is exactly the anchor-3 defect, though it is the sole instance. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 0-8 are clearly sequenced with explicit validation gates throughout: backup before the destructive overwrite ("Never silently destroy existing work"), the Step 3.5 audit requiring "Resolve all mismatches before Step 4", a review-fix loop ("Apply CRITICAL and MAJOR fixes. Document MINOR issues for the user"), and a 15-item final checklist. This matches the anchor for clear sequence, explicit validation steps, feedback loops, and checklists for complex processes. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References to shared files are well-signaled with load conditions ("Read ../shared-references/writing-principles.md before drafting the Abstract...", "only when the built-in DBLP/CrossRef workflow is insufficient"), but no bundle files exist in references/, scripts/, or assets/, the referenced templates/ directory is not part of the bundle, and large blocks that belong in reference files (the ~65-line 12-rule prose contract, the five detailed audit passes) are fully inlined. This lands between 'content that should be separate is inline' (3) and 'most content appropriately placed' (4) — the inlining and unverifiable bundle paths keep it at 3. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |