Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-engineered workflow document: the phase sequence, validation lints, and feedback loops are exemplary, and commands/artifact specs are largely executable. It is held back by rule duplication across sections and by a bundle whose body links point to shared-reference files that are not actually shipped with the skill.
Suggestions
Consolidate repeated safety rules into a single section: 'Never fabricate/overpromise', 'Answer friendly reviewers too', and the structural_distinction pattern are each stated 2-3 times across Phase 2, Phase 4, and Key Rules.
Ship or inline the referenced bundle files: all shared-references links (reviewer-backends.md, reviewer-routing.md, review-tracing.md, integration-contract.md) plus save_trace.sh and reviewer_route.py are dangling in this skill directory, leaving reviewer routing and trace-saving steps unverifiable.
Move long artifact specifications (the REVISION_PLAN.md structure with its example checklist, and the reviewer-defensive moves heuristics) into a references/ file so the SKILL.md body stays a navigable overview.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly efficient operational content, but several rules are stated two or three times ('NEVER invent experiments, numbers, derivations, citations, or links' in Phase 4 repeats 'Never fabricate' in Key Rules; 'Answer friendly reviewers too' and the structural_distinction pattern also appear twice), and the Phase 3 manual-identity paragraph is convoluted — matching the 'could be tightened' anchor rather than the padded one below. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Largely executable guidance: an exact MCP stress-test call with config and a full prompt template, concrete commands like '/experiment-bridge "rebuttal/REBUTTAL_EXPERIMENT_PLAN.md"' and '/render-html "rebuttal/REBUTTAL_DRAFT_rich.md"', and a worked checklist example. Minor gaps remain — trace saving is delegated to a chain in an external file and reviewer_route.py resolution is never concretely specified — so it sits just below the fully copy-paste-ready top anchor. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Ten explicitly sequenced phases with resume support ('If rebuttal/REBUTTAL_STATE.md exists → resume from recorded phase'), a dedicated validation phase enumerating eight lints, and explicit feedback loops ('If any hard safety blocker remains → revise before finalizing', re-run lints in Phase 8, hard iteration caps) — matching the top anchor with checkpoints and error-recovery loops throughout. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is well-sectioned and signals references, but none of the referenced files exist in this bundle ('../shared-references/reviewer-backends.md', 'shared-references/reviewer-routing.md', 'shared-references/review-tracing.md', 'save_trace.sh', 'reviewer_route.py' are all dangling), and long specs that belong in reference files (the full REVISION_PLAN.md structure, reviewer calling conventions, defensive-move heuristics) are inlined — matching the 'some structure but could be better organized' anchor rather than the minimal-structure one below. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |