Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-organized, tool-grounded instruction skill: a quick-reference table ties each MCP tool to its trigger condition, and each guide state has a terse, unambiguous workflow with explicit do/don't guidance. Weaknesses are modest — some repeated admonitions, no full example tool calls, and no error/edge-case checkpoints in the workflows.
Suggestions
Consolidate the repeated 'don't re-match / don't fabricate a guide' guidance into a single 核心边界 item and reference it from the state workflows to trim redundant tokens.
Add one complete example call for cat_cafe_create_rich_block and cat_cafe_update_guide_state (full argument shapes) so the two most central tools are copy-paste executable.
Add a checkpoint in workflow 1 for the empty/error result of cat_cafe_get_available_guides (what to say and whether any state should be persisted), and note how to confirm the rich block was created before calling update_guide_state.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is lean — a tool quick-reference table, terse per-state bullets, no padding and no explanation of concepts Claude already knows. Minor repetition keeps it from a 5: the instruction not to re-match or fabricate guides appears in the 核心边界 ("不要因为看到了关键词就擅自造一个引导"), workflow 1 step 5 ("没有合适候选时，直接回答，不要伪造 guide"), and Guide Selection ("不要重新用关键词匹配一次 guide"). | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete and executable for an instruction-only skill: five named MCP tools in a lookup table mapped to when-to-use, exact state-injection formats, and concrete call details like "cat_cafe_update_guide_state(..., status='offered')" and "cat_cafe_guide_control(action='exit')". Not a 5 because no complete example call (full argument list for cat_cafe_create_rich_block or cat_cafe_update_guide_state) is shown, leaving minor execution gaps; not a 3 because the guidance is specific and directly executable, not pseudocode. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | All six states get a clearly sequenced workflow, including an explicit decision tree for the no-state case ("先判断：用户是要一个简短解释，还是要一步一步带着做") and explicit ordering constraints ("在 rich block 之后调用 cat_cafe_update_guide_state"). Not a 5 because there are no verification/checkpoint steps (e.g., how to confirm the rich block was created before persisting state, or what to do if cat_cafe_get_available_guides returns an error/empty set beyond '直接回答'); not a 3 because the sequences themselves are complete and unambiguous with explicit do/don't guardrails per state. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist (no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories), and none are needed: every section (role, boundaries, injection formats, tool table, six state workflows) is core runtime guidance that belongs in SKILL.md, organized under clear headers. Not a 5 because at ~84 body lines it exceeds the under-50-line simple-skill case where organization alone earns top marks, and the six per-state workflows could plausibly live in a reference file; not a 3 because nothing that belongs elsewhere is inlined and navigation is easy. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |