Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A highly actionable, well-validated gate procedure whose commands, thresholds, and report template are copy-paste ready. Its weaknesses are accretion: retrospective incident narratives, dated revision notes, and redundant tables inflate token cost, and several self-contained policies would live better in the already-existing shared-refs pattern than inline.
Suggestions
Move the incident-history and retrospective blocks (F041 lesson, F209 reflection with Phase B/C stories, PR #1854 counterexample, 2026-03-11 lesson, dated revision notes) into a lessons-learned reference file and keep one-line pointers in the body, recovering the conciseness currently spent on narrative padding.
Consolidate the overlapping rows of the Quick Reference and Common Mistakes tables (e.g., stale-evidence, .pen judgment, and screenshot-vs-runtime rows appear in both) into a single table to cut redundancy.
Extract the Step 2.5 close-gate policy (keyword list, exemptions, cvo_signoff checklist) and the Step 4.5 dogfood scope/why/report spec into referenced files like the existing ../.cat-cafe-shared-refs pattern, leaving the flow steps as short pointers.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is noticeably verbose: inline incident history and dated retrospectives ("F041 教训", "F209 反思 2026-05-23", "2026-03-11 教训:三只Ragdoll同时跳过了...", "反例 PR #1854", revision notes like "2026-07-15 修订") are narrative padding a reader does not need to execute the gate, and the rubric explicitly penalizes time-sensitive dates outside a dedicated section. Per the anti-drift check it is above anchor 1 (the bulk is real operational instruction, not general-concept explanation) but clearly below anchor 3, where only 'some' tightening would be needed — several whole sections are retrospective rather than instructional. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The body is fully executable: copy-paste-ready commands ("curl -sf http://localhost:3004/health", "git status --short | rg '^.. [^/]+\.(png|jpe?g|webp|...)'", "node scripts/check-hotfix-pattern.mjs", "pnpm --filter @cat-cafe/api test:redis"), a complete fill-in Quality Gate Report template, concrete dogfood example paths, and explicit decision rules with exact thresholds ("≥3 层 fallback 或累计 ≥5 层"). This matches the 'fully executable; copy-paste ready commands; specific examples cover common cases' anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Step 0→8 sequence has explicit validation checkpoints (Step 7 read output/exit code, BLOCK conditions in Step 2.5/7.5) and genuine feedback loops ("Gate 未通过时:P1 遗漏 → 补完再过 gate", dogfood bugs "必须当轮修"), plus a STOP red-flags list — above anchor 4's 'most checkpoints' and near anchor 5. It falls short of 5 because the accreted sub-step numbering (0, 0.5, 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, 4.5, 7.5) and Step 2.5's long conditional-scope preamble make the actual control flow genuinely hard to follow on first read, which is a sequencing clarity defect rather than a missing validation. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | There is real structure (## 流程, ## Quick Reference, ## Common Mistakes, ## 和其他 skill 的区别) and several clearly signaled one-level-deep references with explicit paths ("../.cat-cafe-shared-refs/close-gate.md", "../.cat-cafe-shared-refs/evidence-output-contract.md", "../.cat-cafe-shared-refs/vision-evidence-workflow.md", "docs/ops/testing-standard.md"), but no bundle files ship with the skill and large self-contained policies (the whole dogfood scope/why/report spec, close-gate matrix, fallback-layer rules) are inlined in the ~290-line body where anchor 3's 'content that should be separate is inline' applies. It is below anchor 4 because the split-out that has happened is only partial. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |