Correct file location

.spec.md extension

Frontmatter present

Frontmatter: name field

Frontmatter: description field

Frontmatter: targets field

API contract code block

Headings used for sections

Inline test links

Test links reference correct files

Single spec for service

Edge cases documented

Output file created

Existing coverage section

Cites list_users as existing

Gap analysis present

Questions are separate items

No redundant questions

Performance/scale addressed

Preliminary scope section

Non-functional gaps identified

Gap-driven questions

Questions are specific and bounded

Output file created

Questions are individual items

Questions are self-contained

Questions ordered by criticality

Questions are specific and bounded

Delivery semantics addressed

Retry/failure handling addressed

Security addressed

No spec created

No implementation proposed

Assessment file created

Process violation identified

In-memory cache limitation noted

TTL behavior documented

Invalidation behavior documented

Cache scope documented

Gaps identified

No spec file created

Draft spec section included

Existing spec referenced

Drift report produced

Broken targets detected

Broken test links detected

Lockout threshold change detected

Session TTL change detected

Updated spec targets corrected

Updated spec test links corrected

Updated spec lockout threshold corrected

Updated spec session TTL corrected

No false positives

Output file created

Existing coverage summarized

Does not propose solutions

Ambiguity of 'slow' analyzed

Ambiguity of 'doesn't find' analyzed

Questions are specific and bounded

Questions are individual items

No redundant questions

Performance gap identified

No implementation attempted

Existing content preserved

Rate limiting section added

Default limit documented

Search endpoint limit documented

429 response documented

Admin multiplier documented

Test links added for rate limiting

Frontmatter preserved

Single spec file

No requirement gathering attempted

.spec.md extension retained

Typo fixed

No spec created or modified

No requirement gathering

Recognizes trivial exception

Changes file produced

Only the typo changed

Review summary file created

Pass/fail per requirement

File references on passing items

Missing requirement identified

Discovered requirement documented

Spec updated with discovered requirement

Test results section

Linked tests referenced

Spec updates section

Targets still accurate

Structured review format