Names the domain (tessl tiles) and mentions some actions (create, package content, configure tile.json), but doesn't comprehensively list what specific operations can be performed with tiles beyond creation.

Clearly answers both what (create tessl tiles containing docs, rules, or skills) and when (explicit 'Use when' clause with multiple trigger scenarios including user intent phrases and specific command patterns).

Excellent coverage of natural trigger phrases users would say: 'create tile from', 'convert to tile', 'turn into tile', 'make tile from', 'tile this repo', plus mentions of 'docs, rules, or skills' and 'tile.json configuration'.

Highly distinctive with domain-specific terminology ('tessl tiles', 'tile.json') and unique trigger phrases that are unlikely to conflict with other skills. The specific product/tool focus creates a clear niche.

Content is lean and efficient, using tables and checklists to convey information densely. No unnecessary explanations of concepts Claude would already know; every section serves a clear purpose.

Provides concrete, executable commands for both MCP tool and CLI options with specific parameter examples. The code blocks are copy-paste ready with clear flag explanations.

Clear decision checklist for content types, explicit validation step (tessl tile lint), and well-organized workflow references. The critical path rule about absolute paths and workspace flag is explicitly called out.

Excellent structure with overview content inline and detailed workflows/references clearly signaled as one-level-deep links. The references section provides clear navigation to supporting materials.