matthew-a-carr/review-spec
Cross-artefact consistency and quality review of an approved or draft SPEC. Use when the user says "review SPEC-NNN," before `implement-spec` runs, or by `draft-spec` / `revise-spec` before opening or updating a spec PR. Checks the SPEC against the constitution, ADRs, parent epic (if any), and tech debt register. Read-only — produces a structured report, never edits files.
78
90%
Does it follow best practices?
Impact
80%
1.42xAverage score across 1 eval scenario
Passed
No known issues
Evaluation results
80%
24%Review a User Role Management Specification
Clean SPEC ready verdict and read-only behavior
Verdict: Ready for implementation
0%
0%
All four report sections present
41%
100%
Clean passes explicitly noted
20%
100%
ADRs verified correctly
60%
100%
Result type pattern confirmed
0%
37%
Tech debt TD-010 linkage Suggestion
75%
100%
No inputs modified
100%
100%
Does not invoke implement-spec
100%
100%
Section-prefixed findings or notes
100%
100%
SPEC quoted where relevant
100%
100%
- Evaluated
- Agent
- Claude Code
- Model
- Claude Sonnet 4.6
Table of Contents