Content
52%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body demonstrates sophisticated domain expertise — detailed format contracts, taxonomy disambiguation, and a well-checkpointed review workflow with adversarial validation. Its two real problems are the missing `logic-review-guide.md`, which the process depends on for key step details, and substantial repetition of the five-field format contract across at least five sections.
Suggestions
Bundle `logic-review-guide.md` (e.g., in references/) or inline the essential content of the guide steps it cites — the premise/type/state checklists (Step 2), the three rebuttal questions (Step 5.5), and the Logic Score formula (Step 7) — since the file is referenced ~15 times but does not exist in the bundle.
Consolidate the five-field label discipline into one authoritative statement (e.g., in the Output Skeleton Contract section) and reference it from Steps 5 and 6 instead of restating the full label list and the 'Divergence is not optional' warning in each place.
Move the four L-code disambiguation paragraphs (L1 vs L6, L2 vs L6, L5 vs L7, L9) into the guide or a reference table; they are valuable but interrupt the Process step sequence and inflate the core SKILL.md token budget.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly high-value, non-obvious guidance (L-code disambiguation rules, formatting pitfalls tied to specific eval failures) and does not explain concepts Claude already knows. However, the five-field label discipline is restated at least five times (the pitfalls section, line 41, Step 5's no-bug discipline, Step 6, and the no-bug example), and the "Divergence is not optional" point is repeated nearly verbatim across sections — clear tightening opportunities that keep it below anchor 4. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Two complete, copy-paste-ready finding templates (critical and no-bug cases) and concrete disambiguation rules ("any state access involving more than one execution context ... is L7, never L4") are strong. But the substance of Steps 1–8 repeatedly defers to a guide that is not bundled — "using the name, type, state and control checks in guide Step 2", "guide Step 5.5", "compute the bounded Logic Score using guide Step 7" — so key executable details (the premise checklists, the three rebuttal questions, the scoring formula) are simply missing, matching anchor 3's 'incomplete; missing key details'. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 0–8 are clearly sequenced with unusually strong validation checkpoints: an adversarial red-team step with withdraw/downgrade rules, a reachability gate, a remedy dry-run, and an optional execution verification gate that withdraws false positives — a genuine feedback loop. The gap keeping it below anchor 5 is that several checkpoints' operational detail (rebuttal question content, scoring computation) lives only in the unbundled guide, leaving those steps implicitly defined. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body points to exactly one bundle file — "Use only the relevant steps in `logic-review-guide.md` as you reach them" — and cites "guide Step N" roughly fifteen times, but that file does not exist anywhere in the bundle (no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories). The reference is one level deep and clearly signaled, but it is broken: all deferred content is unreachable, which is a structural failure the rubric's 'minimal structure / buried references' anchor 2 captures better than the well-organized anchors 4–5. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |