Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a rigorously specified, fully actionable six-phase workflow with outstanding validation discipline — denominator reporting for every scan, a deterministic Go/No-Go precedence rule, tier-gated output, and user confirmation for unresolvable items. Its weaknesses are repetition (the cert_tier rule restated and re-justified in multiple places) and a large inlined checklist template that belongs in a separate reference file, which together cost both conciseness and progressive-disclosure points.
Suggestions
Move the Phase 4 checklist template to a bundle file such as references/checklist-template.md and reference it from the phase (e.g., "Render the template from references/checklist-template.md"), cutting the SKILL.md body roughly in half.
State the cert_tier gating rule once in the scope section and have the Platform Certification section point back to it ("gated per the cert_tier rule above") instead of restating and re-justifying it with blockquotes.
Compress rationale blockquotes ("Emitting every item for every platform trains the reader to skip the list...", "A test on target platforms treats an itch project and a steam project identically...") into single-line imperatives such as "Branch on cert_tier values, never platform names."
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The bulk is dense, project-specific instruction Claude would not know (config keys, phases, gating rules), but it could be tightened: the cert_tier rule is stated three times (top scope section, Platform Certification section, and the "> Branch on the cert_tier values above" blockquote), and rationale blockquotes like "Emitting every item for every platform trains the reader to skip the list, which defeats the gate" and "A test on target platforms treats an itch project and a steam project identically..." explain why at essay length. This is anchor 3 (mostly efficient, some unnecessary explanation), not 2, since nothing explains concepts Claude already knows and the duplication is limited to a few motifs. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable for an instruction-only skill: exact search targets ("TODO, FIXME, HACK", "console.log, print()", "placeholder, temp_, WIP_"), exact output strings ("[?] = not assessed — the input to this check was absent"), a complete copy-paste-ready checklist template, exact AskUserQuestion option labels, an exact write path ("production/releases/launch-checklist-[date].md"), and a deterministic first-match-wins Go/No-Go rule. Anchor 5 — specific guidance covers the common cases with no gaps. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Six clearly ordered phases with explicit validation checkpoints throughout: "Establish the denominator before every scan, and report it", Phase 4b user confirmation, explicit failure handling ("If it cannot be determined, mark the section NOT ASSESSED — cert tier unknown"), and a permission gate before the only write ("Create nothing before the answer — not even the production/releases/ directory"). The destructive/batch validation cap does not apply: the sole write is gated by dry-run mode and explicit permission. Matches anchor 5 — clear sequence, explicit checkpoints, checklists for the complex process, and error-recovery paths for every failure mode. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist (references/, scripts/, assets/ are absent), and external references are exceptionally well signaled and bounded ("read only that section (Grep its heading, then a bounded Read)" for .claude/docs/effects-map.md). However, the ~230-line checklist template inlined in Phase 4 is content that clearly belongs in a separate template file — it roughly doubles the SKILL.md body. This fits anchor 3 (content that should be separate is inline); it is not 4 because the inlined template is a major placement gap, not a minor one, and not 2 because overall structure and navigation are otherwise good. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |