Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, mostly executable phased workflow with genuine operational edge-case handling and explicit validation/failure behavior. The main gaps are a CWD-relative path for the bundled preprocessing script, an unspecified validation command in Phase 5, and long edge-case bash blocks that could be offloaded to reference files.
Suggestions
Reference the bundled preprocessing script via an explicit skill-relative path (e.g. scripts/extract-domain-context.py resolved from the skill directory) rather than the CWD-relative './extract-domain-context.py'.
Make Phase 5's validation concrete: name the actual validation command/script and the schema it validates against, instead of 'the standard graph validation pipeline'.
Move the worktree-redirect and plugin-root-resolution bash blocks into a reference file (e.g. references/plugin-root.md) to keep SKILL.md a leaner overview.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dominated by executable operational bash with justified edge-case handling (worktree redirect, plugin-root resolution), not explanations of concepts Claude already knows. Minor over-explanation could be trimmed — the 8-candidate error listing repeats every path, and the 'cheap Python preprocessing → expensive LLM' rationale sentence is padding. Not 5 because of these small trimmable passages. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides mostly executable guidance: complete bash blocks for worktree detection, $UA_DIR resolution, plugin-root candidate loop, and git freshness checks, plus the concrete 'python ./extract-domain-context.py "$PROJECT_ROOT"' invocation. Not 5 because the script path is CWD-relative with no bundled script directory present, and Phase 5's 'Validate using the standard graph validation pipeline' names no command or script. Not 3 because the concrete commands cover the common path end-to-end. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear Phase 0–6 sequence with explicit decision points (existing graph vs fresh scan, --full override), a freshness preflight with project-scoped pathspec handling, error-tolerance guidance ('warn and continue instead of blocking'), and a validation checkpoint in Phase 5. Not 5 because the validation step itself is abstract — no concrete validation command or fix-and-retry loop is given. Not 3 because validation and failure behavior are explicitly addressed. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Well-organized phase sections with one-level-deep, explicitly pathed references (the bundled extract-domain-context.py preprocessing script and $PLUGIN_ROOT/agents/domain-analyzer.md); ~160 lines of operational workflow inline is appropriate placement. Not 5 because the two long edge-case bash blocks (worktree redirect, plugin-root resolution) could live in a reference file to keep SKILL.md a leaner overview, and the referenced bundled script has no visible bundle structure. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |