Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-built orchestration skill body: lean, policy-dense, with a clear phase sequence, explicit validation for config resolution and grounding failure, and disciplined delegation to a verified, appropriately-sized reference bundle. The main gaps are that the workflow's later phases and part of the bundle are only discoverable by chaining reads, and a little redundancy could be trimmed.
Suggestions
Add a short bundle map (one line per file, including agents/) so files like html-rendering.md, markdown-rendering.md, publishing.md, and the agent briefs are discoverable from SKILL.md instead of only via chained reads through other references.
Name phases 3-5 in the body — even one line each before the post-ideation-workflow.md handoff — so the full workflow shape is visible up front rather than emerging through reference chaining.
Trim the repeated "The read is required" assertions and condense the marker-comment blocks (ce-docs-root, ce-config-layers) to recover tokens without losing the policies they encode.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense operational policy with no explanation of concepts Claude already knows, but carries minor trimmable redundancy: "The read is required" is asserted repeatedly, the ce-docs-root/ce-config-layers marker blocks add bulk, and some lawyerly sentences ("Presence in the current tool list is proof the tool exists") could be tightened. It is not 5 because of that residual slack, and not 3 because nothing is concept-explanation padding. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable coordination guidance throughout: exact paths (`<root>/ideation/`, `/tmp/compound-engineering-<uid>`), a real command (`git rev-parse --show-toplevel`), and specific directives ("Generate one 8-hex `<run-id>`"), with ordered required reads per phase. It is not 5 because the body alone is not copy-paste executable for the core generation work (fleet, frames, and rules are delegated to references), and not 3 because the guidance actually present is specific and executable rather than high-level hints. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Phases 0→1→1.5→2 are clearly sequenced with explicit read-ordering and real validation checkpoints ("Otherwise stop with an error naming `docs_root` and the value -- never fall back", "Warn and proceed when grounding fails"). It is not 5 because phases after Phase 2 are invisible in the body and the handoff sentence ("continue with `references/post-ideation-workflow.md`, which it names as the next required read") is convoluted; it is not 3 because sequence and checkpoints are explicit for everything the body covers. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is a lean phase index whose seven directly referenced files (output-mode.md, scope-gates.md, grounding.md, decomposition.md, divergent-ideation.md, universal-ideation.md, post-ideation-workflow.md) all exist and contain real, well-sized content (27-247 lines each), with references clearly signaled. It is not 5 because several bundle files (html-rendering.md, markdown-rendering.md, ideation-sections.md, publishing.md, and agents/*) are reachable only by chaining through other references, and reference files cross-reference each other extensively (post-ideation-workflow.md alone points to six more), so navigation extends beyond one level; it is not 3 because the structure and signaling are clearly good. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |