Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a dense, well-validated operational contract with genuinely strong actionability — exact parameters, commands, gates, and failure semantics — but it is padded by heavy cross-section repetition and keeps all reference-grade detail inline with no progressive-disclosure split, and the bolted-on adaptation section dilutes the otherwise crisp tool story.
Suggestions
State each tool's scope once (in its Tools subsection) and replace the repeated refresh/caching guarantees elsewhere with a single cross-reference; this would cut roughly 20% of the body.
Move the Evidence Row Contract, decay threshold tables, and cost-screen derivation into a references/ file (e.g., EVIDENCE.md), keeping SKILL.md as the routing-and-semantics overview.
Reconcile the tool count and integrate "Description-driven adaptation" properly — the body says "the three query tools… the fourth tool" while later declaring adapt_strategy "the fifth tool", and the adaptation workflow itself is compressed and unclear about when to choose it.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly domain-specific contract detail Claude cannot derive (thresholds, gates, fail-closed semantics), but the same refresh/caching guarantees are restated across ~5 sections ("rebuilds the disposable cache from run artifacts… it is NOT strategy creation" appears in When to Use, Tools, Populating, Honest-Empty, and Composition Guarantee), and "no network, no credentials" is repeated twice in one section. Could be tightened without losing information — not anchor 2 because the bulk is non-derivable, not filler. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete parameter tables for all tools, exact CLI invocations ("vibe-trading strategy-evidence refresh --manifest <path>"), a copy-paste manifest JSON example, the breakeven formula, and exact hard-gate failure tokens. Not a 5 because there are no example tool calls or example response rows/envelopes to anchor expected outputs. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The routing decision tree, the ordered 5-gate hard-gate checklist with stable failure tokens and per-entry skip reasons, and the 3-step periodic recipe provide explicit validation and feedback loops. Not a 5 because the appended "Description-driven adaptation" section introduces a fifth tool with a muddier workflow and stale contradictions ("the three query tools" vs. the earlier "four tools" framing), slightly muddying the overall sequence. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Well-sectioned with clear headers and internal cross-references ("see Populating & Refreshing Evidence"), but there are no bundle files at all — all ~200 lines of evidence-row contract, decay tables, cost-screen math, and gate definitions live inline in SKILL.md. Content that clearly belongs in a reference file (e.g., the evidence row contract and decay thresholds) is inline, matching anchor 3. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |