Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is an exceptionally dense, executable operational manual with best-in-class validation loops in the create/refresh workflows. Its one real structural defect is progressive disclosure: every `artifact-type/reference/*.md` pointer dangles in this bundle, and peripheral feature detail is inlined rather than split out.
Suggestions
Ship the referenced files: `artifact-type/reference/design-defaults.md`, `one-writer.md`, `features.md`, `exporting.md`, `remix.md`, `looks.md` and `design-system.md` are named throughout — the Design step depends on two of them — but none exist in the bundle, so every 'read X first' instruction dead-ends.
Move the Sharing, History and Comments sections (~120 lines) into reference files, as the body already does for features/exporting/remix, keeping SKILL.md focused on the create/fill/check/refresh loop.
Trim the History section's merge-semantics detail ('Compare, Bring back, Dismiss', line-merge rules, saved-over notices) to what the agent must act on; the rest is reader-facing UI behavior the page itself explains.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Telegraphic, skill-specific prose that assumes competence ('d3 v7 is the global d3: helpers for common tasks. Where it lacks something, the page's own code does it') and explains nothing Claude already knows; the deduction is periphery length — the Sharing and History sections run ~45 lines each on guest-link and merge semantics detail that could be trimmed or moved out. Not a 3: there is no unnecessary explanation, only volume from genuine feature surface. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable throughout: a complete command table (`node $A write-db <root> <batch.json | ->`, `check`, `open` with flags), a copy-paste JSON batch example for a source refresh, the `{"$file": "<path>"}` pattern, concrete `dash.data(id)`/`dash.calc(id, {inputs, fn, title, description})` signatures, and a complete pre-commit hook script — the common cases are covered with copy-paste-ready commands. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The create workflow is numbered (Find the data → Design → Write) with explicit validation and bounded feedback loops: 'run `check <root>`… fix what it lists and run it again until `problems` is 0', then the page's own check with 'checking: run it again, 5 times at most' and 'failed:… write, check again, 2 fixes max; still failed: say so' — batch writes are validated, so no cap applies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References are clearly signaled and one level deep, but the actual bundle contains no `artifact-type/reference/` directory — the Design step's load-bearing 'read `artifact-type/reference/design-defaults.md` and `one-writer.md` first' points at files that do not exist here, and ~120 lines of Sharing/History/Comments operational detail is inlined that belongs in separate files. Not a 2: headers, tables and per-document sections keep the structure far from 'minimal' or 'buried'; not a 4: the navigation the body depends on dead-ends. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |