Content
61%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The content is a well-sectioned, mostly executable dispatch guide with a real command, argument table, and error handling, held back by a duplicated contract section and the absence of a worked payload example. Most importantly, a batch PR-closing operation ships without result verification or dry-run-first guidance, capping workflow clarity.
Suggestions
Remove the 'Contract' section or reduce it to the one item not already in the runtime-truth block (the backing node path) — the command name and both topics are stated verbatim twice.
Add a filled example payload (e.g., '{"repos": ["org/repo"], "label": "dependencies", "dry_run": true}') so the dispatch command is copy-paste ready.
Add a verification checkpoint for the destructive close path: recommend 'dry_run: true' first, then confirm the reported prs_closed/prs_kept groups before dispatching without it.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body assumes Claude's competence and explains no general concepts, but the 'Contract' section repeats the command name and both topics already given in the generated runtime-truth block, and the binding/evidence wire-schema detail (terminal_selection enum, schema_version lineage) exceeds what a self-described 'thin shim' needs. Not 4 because the duplication and over-detailed evidence fields are more than minor trimmable instances; not 2 because everything present is domain-specific truth rather than padding or explanations of known concepts. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | The dispatch section gives a concrete, mostly executable command with real flags ('env -u PYTHONPATH uv run python scripts/run_codex_runtime_request.py --command-name ... --timeout-ms 600000'), an argument table with defaults, an explicit payload field list, and concrete error-handling guidance ('surface error.code and error.message'). Not 5 because '--payload '<json-payload>'' is a placeholder with no filled example payload covering the common case. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence (map arguments → build payload → dispatch → interpret ok/error → render output) is present and the '--compile-only' preflight is an explicit checkpoint, but the skill drives a batch, destructive operation (bulk-closing superseded PRs) with no result-verification step, no dry-run-first guidance despite 'dry_run' existing as an argument, and no fix-and-retry loop on failure. The rubric's destructive/batch cap of 3 applies: checkpoints for the close operation itself are missing or implicit. Not 2 because the sequence is well-defined and preflight/error paths are stated. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is cleanly sectioned (Arguments, Runtime truth, Dispatch, Contract, Output) with all content appropriately in SKILL.md for a thin single-purpose adapter, and the only file reference ('scripts/run_codex_runtime_request.py') is a real script in the target repo per the 'Run from the omnimarket repo' instruction — though no bundle files exist to verify. Not 5 because at ~108 lines the generated runtime-truth block could live in a reference file, and the duplicated Contract section adds navigation noise. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |