Content
73%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured orchestrator skill with an exemplary gated workflow: explicit sequencing, human checkpoints with defined branches, a bounded auto-review feedback loop, and concrete skill-invocation commands and templates. Its weaknesses are token efficiency — duplicated sub-skill descriptions, a flavor timeline section, and a time-sensitive model reference — and slightly vague Stage 2 implementation guidance.
Suggestions
Trim the Stage 3/4 "What this does" bullet lists to one line each (the invoked sub-skills' own SKILL.md files own that detail), and cut the "Typical Timeline" table and "sweet spot" narrative to save tokens.
Remove or abstract the time-sensitive "GPT-5.4 xhigh" model reference (e.g., make the reviewer model a config constant like REVIEWER_DIFFICULTY) so the skill does not go stale.
Make Stage 2 concrete: link an experiment scaffold/template (e.g., a seeded, argparse-configured training script skeleton in a references/ file) instead of generic directives like "extend pilot code to full scale".
Fix the fragile external reference by moving RESEARCH_BRIEF_TEMPLATE.md into this skill's own folder (e.g., references/RESEARCH_BRIEF_TEMPLATE.md) so the link resolves within the skill bundle.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly operational (constants, stages, gates, rules) but includes unnecessary material: the "What this does" bullet lists for Stages 3–4 re-describe sub-skills that own their own documentation, the "Typical Timeline" table and "sweet spot" bedtime advice are flavor, and "GPT-5.4 xhigh" is a time-sensitive version reference not in a deprecated section. This fits anchor 3 (mostly efficient, some unnecessary explanation or could be tightened) better than anchor 4's 'minor instances'. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides concrete, copy-paste-ready artifacts: exact skill invocations (`/aris-idea-discovery "$ARGUMENTS"`, `/aris-auto-review-loop "$ARGUMENTS — [chosen idea title], difficulty: $REVIEWER_DIFFICULTY"`), a Gate 1 presentation template, and a full final-report markdown template. Stage 2's implementation guidance ("Extend pilot code to full scale", "Follow existing codebase conventions") remains high-level and idea-dependent, leaving minor gaps that fit anchor 4. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five stages are clearly sequenced with explicit validation checkpoints and feedback loops: Gate 1 branches (approve / pick different / request changes → re-run with refined constraints / reject / stop), AUTO_PROCEED semantics, Stage 2's self-review checklist, Stage 3's "Verify experiments started successfully" plus monitoring, and Stage 4's bounded retry loop ("repeat until score ≥ 6/10 or 4 rounds") with a stop rule if round 4 ends negative. This matches anchor 5's explicit validation, error-recovery loops, and checklists; anchor 4 would require missing checkpoints, and validation is present so no destructive/batch cap applies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The skill has no bundle files; the body is organized into clear sections (Constants, Overview, Pipeline, Key Rules, Timeline) and its one external reference — `RESEARCH_BRIEF_TEMPLATE.md` via a clearly signaled one-level-deep markdown link — is appropriately placed. It falls short of anchor 5 because the reference points outside the skill folder (`../aris-infra/`), which is fragile, and the ~170-line body inlines presentation/report templates that could be split out, fitting anchor 4's 'minor organization gaps'. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |