Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, gated workflow protocol with genuinely concrete tool-call syntax, explicit stop/exit conditions, and clean one-level-deep references. Its main liability is substantial structural redundancy — exit criteria, memory rules, and stop rules are each restated two to three times across sections — inflating the body well beyond what the guidance requires.
Suggestions
Merge the duplicated exit criteria ('### 8. Stop on clarity, not exhaustion' and '## Exit criteria') into one section and state each rule once; the same applies to the memory-before-search rules given in 'Non-negotiable rules', '### 2.1', and 'Memory rules'.
Move detail-heavy schemas (paper-card metadata fields, search-ladder buckets, scouting ledger fields, baseline-scoring criteria) into the existing reference files so SKILL.md reads as an overview.
Define a concrete scale or rubric for the six baseline-candidate scoring criteria (e.g., high/medium/low with a decision rule) so the shortlist step is executable rather than judgment-only.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~525-line body repeats whole rule clusters: exit criteria appear nearly verbatim in both '### 8. Stop on clarity, not exhaustion' and '## Exit criteria'; memory-search-before-web guidance is given three times (Non-negotiable rules, '### 2.1', 'Memory rules'); stop-search rules and template pointers are each stated twice. This is noticeably verbose with several padded/duplicated sections, though the padding is structural redundancy rather than explanations of concepts Claude already knows, keeping it above 1. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete for an instruction-only skill: exact tool calls with parameters (`memory.list_recent(scope='quest', limit=5)`, `artifact.arxiv(paper_id=..., full_text=False)`, `memory.write(...)` with a tags array example), named output files (`brief.md`, `artifacts/scout/*.md`), and template pointers for output shapes. It misses 5 because some directives stay abstract — baseline candidates must be 'scored' on six criteria with no scale or rubric defined, and the scouting ledger has no concrete format inline. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The numbered workflow (reconstruct frame → identify unknowns → reuse memory → search neighborhood → eval contract → baseline shortlist → next anchor → update continuity) is clearly sequenced, with explicit checkpoints: a preconditions gate over `brief.md`/`plan.md`/`status.md`, per-search stop rules, an exit checklist, and a blocked-state error path with a structured 'ask the user' branch. It falls short of 5 because several checkpoints are implicit conditions rather than verifiable validation steps, and the durable writes have no verification step. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | All four referenced files (`paper-triage-playbook.md`, `literature-scout-template.md`, `eval-contract-template.md`, `baseline-shortlist-template.md`) exist, are clearly signaled at the point of need, and are one level deep with no nested references (verified by grep). Good structure with clear section headers; it misses 5 because the SKILL.md body is a full 525-line protocol rather than an overview — detail like paper-card metadata lists and the search-ladder/ledger schemas would fit better in reference files. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |