Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-engineered operational skill: safety-critical boundaries, a validated multi-step workflow with verification at every destructive stage, and an exemplary progressive-disclosure structure verified against a real one-level-deep bundle. The main gaps are the absence of any literal copy-paste invocation in the body and minor repetition across sections.
Suggestions
Include one complete example invocation in the body (e.g., `python $SKILL_DIR/scripts/hcp.py create --execute --profile <run>/profile.json --state-dir <run>/state`) so the most common command is copy-paste ready without opening operations.md.
De-duplicate repeated admonitions such as "Never label unperformed checks as passed" (Workflow preamble and Step 1) and consolidate the AWS secret_creds key/alias enumeration into providers.md or operations.md, keeping only the pointer in the body.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense with non-obvious domain constraints (management/guest/infrastructure credential separation, "--render is not a safe planning operation", SingleReplica policy, attempt-receipt blocking) and never explains concepts Claude already knows. Minor trimmable material remains: "Never label unperformed checks as passed" appears in both the Workflow preamble and Step 1, and a few long prose passages (e.g., the AWS secret_creds key/alias enumeration) could be tightened. Not 5 because of this repetition and padding; not 3 because nearly all content is skill-specific knowledge Claude cannot infer. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete guidance throughout: named helper subcommands (plan, preflight, create --execute, access, deploy --execute, inventory, verify-cleanup, destroy --execute), script paths, profile file modes (0700/0600), and specific flags (--role-arn, SingleReplica). Not 5 because no literal copy-paste invocation line (e.g., `python $SKILL_DIR/scripts/hcp.py create --execute --profile ...`) appears in the body — exact syntax is deferred to operations.md — leaving a minor gap for the most common case. Not 3: the guidance is executable in substance, not pseudocode or vague direction. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 7-step workflow (plan/preflight → present plan & create → observe readiness → access → deploy → verify → teardown) is clearly sequenced with explicit validation checkpoints at every risky stage: preflight scope limits, readiness evidence beyond Available=True, guest UID checks, smoke tests, and inventory review plus verify-cleanup before/after destroy. Feedback loops are present ("reconcile existing provider resources before any retry", timeout/partial-failure recovery in operations.md, "do not clear the receipt to make a failing check pass"). This matches the anchor-5 pattern including for the destructive teardown path. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Verified against the actual bundle: all 10 references/, 4 assets/, and 3 scripts/ files cited in the body exist, and reference-file cross-links (operations.md → teardown.md/bootstrap.md, accelerators.md → guest-operators.md) are sibling-level, one level deep with no nested chains. Each reference is signaled twice with purpose and a conditional read trigger (bootstrap.md only when installation is explicitly requested, accelerators.md for mixed pools, inference-benchmarks.md for measurements). Not 4: content split is appropriate for a complex lifecycle skill and navigation is unambiguous despite the long overview. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 18 / 20 Passed |