Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill body is highly actionable with a well-sequenced eight-step workflow and exact commands, formats, and examples, but it pays for this with substantial internal repetition (the requirements-vs-implementation distinction and hook protocol are each stated multiple times) and no use of progressive disclosure — everything lives inline in one long file. Consolidating the duplicated sections and moving example catalogs to reference files would improve both weak dimensions without losing any executable guidance.
Suggestions
State the 'requirements quality, not implementation testing' principle once (in the purpose section) and delete its re-explanations in step 6, 'Example Checklist Types', and 'Anti-Examples', keeping only a single set of wrong/right examples.
Extract the per-dimension example catalog and the four sample checklists (UX/API/performance/security) into a references/examples.md file, and factor the extension-hook protocol into one shared section or reference file referenced by both Pre- and Post-Execution checks.
Add an explicit post-generation validation step, e.g., re-read the written checklist to confirm ≥80% of items carry a traceability reference and that IDs continue correctly, with a fix-and-retry loop if not.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is noticeably verbose through heavy duplication rather than generic concept explanation: the 'unit tests for requirements' idea is restated in at least four places (purpose section, step 6 'CORE PRINCIPLE', 'Example Checklist Types', 'Anti-Examples'), examples like 'Is prominent display quantified' and the logo-fallback item appear three times each, and the entire extension-hook protocol is repeated verbatim between the Pre-Execution and Post-Execution Checks. This matches anchor 2 ('noticeably verbose; several unnecessary explanations or padded sections'). It is not score 1 because the content is domain-specific guidance rather than explanations of concepts Claude already knows, and not score 3 because the repetition is substantial enough that the same instructions could be roughly halved. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: an exact command ('Run .specify/scripts/bash/check-prerequisites.sh --json --template checklist-template ... and parse JSON for FEATURE_DIR, AVAILABLE_DOCS list, and TEMPLATE_CONTENT'), concrete file-naming rules ('[domain].md', 'ux.md', 'api.md'), explicit ID continuation logic ('if last item is CHK015, start new items at CHK016'), exact item format patterns with wrong/right examples, and per-domain sample checklists (UX, API, performance, security) covering the common cases. This matches the anchor 5 'fully executable; specific examples cover the common cases' — only trivially below would be anchor 4, which requires minor gaps that are not evident here. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The eight Execution Steps form a clear, ordered sequence with concrete checkpoints: a prerequisites script whose JSON output is parsed, an IF EXISTS conditional load of constitution.md, a bounded clarification stage (max five questions with skip rules), explicit append-vs-create file handling that preserves existing content ('Never delete or replace existing checklist content'), a specified error path for unparseable extensions.yml (report the parser error, then continue), and a final Report step. This fits anchor 4 ('clear sequence with most checkpoints present; minor validation gaps'). It falls short of anchor 5 because there is no post-generation validation loop (e.g., verifying the written checklist parses or that traceability coverage ≥80% actually holds), only an aspiration stated as a requirement. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body has clear ## section structure but is a ~375-line monolith with no bundle files at all: content that would naturally live one level deep — the extensive examples-by-quality-dimension catalog, the four per-domain sample checklists, the anti-examples section, and the (duplicated) hook protocol — is all inlined in SKILL.md, matching anchor 3 ('some structure but could be better organized; content that should be separate is inline'). It is not anchor 4 because nothing is split out into references, and not anchor 2 because sections are well-labeled and navigable rather than an unstructured dump; the under-50-lines exception to score 5 clearly does not apply. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |