Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is an impressively rigorous command spec: exact commands, resolution orders, validation loops, and completion criteria make it highly actionable and workflow-clear. Its weaknesses are duplication (the hook protocol appears twice) and monolithic structure — a 330-line single file where a checklist template and hook protocol reference would reduce token cost and improve navigation.
Suggestions
Factor the shared extension-hook processing rules (extensions.yml parsing, enabled/condition handling, dot-to-hyphen command mapping) into a single referenced file or one shared section, and have both Pre- and Post-Execution sections reference it instead of duplicating ~25 lines each.
Move the full Specification Quality Checklist template to a referenced file (e.g., references/requirements-checklist.md) and keep only the validation procedure inline, cutting ~35 lines from the body.
Remove guidance that re-teaches known behavior, such as the 'CRITICAL - Table Formatting' spacing/preview rules and the 'For AI Generation' restatement of the clarification limits already specified in step 6.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly task-specific operational detail that earns its place, but the ~25-line extension-hook protocol is duplicated nearly verbatim in Pre-Execution Checks and Mandatory Post-Execution Hooks, the 'For AI Generation' section re-states the clarification limits from step 6, and table-formatting rules ('Each cell should have spaces around content', 'Test that the table renders correctly in markdown preview') explain what Claude already knows. Not 2 because the bulk is concrete instruction rather than concept padding. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable guidance: exact commands ('.specify/scripts/bash/resolve-template.sh spec-template --json'), an explicit resolution order for SPECIFY_FEATURE_DIRECTORY, a literal JSON payload for .specify/feature.json, complete hook output templates, worked short-name examples, and good/bad success-criteria examples. Instruction-only skill whose guidance is copy-paste ready; matches anchor 5. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear sequence (pre-hooks → 8-step outline → quality validation → post-hooks → completion report) with explicit validation steps, a feedback loop ('Re-run validation until all items pass (max 3 iterations)'), numbered clarification questions with a defined response format, and a 'Done When' checklist. Matches anchor 5: explicit validation, feedback loops, and checklists for a complex process. Not 4 — no checkpoints are missing. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist (no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories), so everything lives in a ~330-line SKILL.md. Section headers are clear, but content that clearly belongs in separate files — the 35-line checklist template and the duplicated hook protocol — is inlined, and there are no references at all. Fits anchor 3: some structure, but content that should be separate is inline. Not 4 because there is no reference navigation and the monolithic size impairs scanning. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |