Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body presents a well-sequenced, gated four-stage workflow with genuinely concrete confirmation prompts and tool calls, but its progressive disclosure is broken: every core stage depends on workflow SOP files whose paths are never given, and the existing references/ and scripts/ files are orphaned. Repetition of error-handling and precedence rules across three sections also costs conciseness.
Suggestions
Add the missing 'Skill File Index' section listing the absolute paths of workflows/sop-exploration.md, sop-design.md, sop-verification.md, sop-load-template.md, and sop-generation.md — or ship those files in the bundle — so the per-stage 'read_file' instructions are executable.
Reference the existing bundle files from the body (e.g., point the A4 review stage at references/deliverable-review.md and A2.1 verification at references/feasibility-checklist.md) so they are discoverable.
De-duplicate <condition>: the identical 'Execution precedence' line appears twice, and the abort/missing-file messaging in <guideline>, [A1.1], and <condition> should be consolidated to a single canonical wording.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is operational throughout — structured prompts, tool calls, hard limits — with no explanation of concepts Claude already knows. It falls short of a 5 because of verbatim duplication (the 'Execution precedence: Mandatory prechecks → Stage sequence (A1→A2→A3→A4)' line appears twice in <condition>) and abort/error messaging repeated with divergent wording across <guideline>, [A1.1], and <condition>. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | The confirmation gates are copy-paste ready (exact JSON query/options blocks, 'Call `sdd_advance` tool with `stage=design_review`', the 3000-char chunked-write rule), but the core work of stages A1.2–A3.2 is delegated to 'workflows/sop-*.md' files whose paths are never provided — the promised 'Skill File Index' section does not exist in the document. Some concrete but incomplete guidance with missing key details fits the 3 anchor, not the 4 anchor's 'minor gaps'. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The A1→A2→A3→A4 sequence is explicit with per-stage completion criteria, structured user confirmation gates, effort-based exceptions, and precise skip semantics ('Do NOT enter the review stage in order to skip it'). It is not a 5 because verification and per-stage execution details live in the inaccessible SOP files rather than explicit validation steps in this document. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Scored against the actual bundle: all five references to 'workflows/sop-exploration.md', 'sop-design.md', 'sop-verification.md', 'sop-load-template.md', 'sop-generation.md' point to a nonexistent directory via a 'Skill File Index' section that is absent, while existing bundle files (references/deliverable-review.md, references/feasibility-checklist.md, scripts/assemble-checklist.mjs, scripts/assemble-template.mjs) are never referenced from the body. Navigation to the detail layer is broken, fitting the 2 anchor ('references are buried' / minimal effective structure); not 1 because there is no multi-level nesting and the body itself is well-sectioned. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |