Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A tightly written, professionally structured auditor skill with an explicit gated workflow, validation checkpoints, and persistence feedback loops. Its main weaknesses are progressive disclosure: the majority of referenced runbooks, benchmarks, and the validation script live outside the bundle as unverifiable relative paths, and reference listings are duplicated between the Runtime Reads and Reference Materials sections.
Suggestions
Bundle or inline the essential content from the out-of-skill references (auditor-runbook.md, scoring-semantics.md, roas-benchmark.md, runtime-invocation.md) so every referenced path resolves within the skill folder instead of pointing three levels up to '../../../references/'.
Deduplicate the reference lists: 'Runtime Reads' and 'Reference Materials' both cite auditor-runbook.md, scoring-semantics.md, and roas-benchmark.md — consolidate into a single clearly signaled section.
Ship 'validate-audit-artifact.py' in a scripts/ folder (or state its canonical location and how to obtain it) since the Persistence workflow depends on it but it is absent from the bundle.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and assumes competence — it never explains concepts Claude already knows and every section carries operational content ('Score all 20 R1..S5 criteria from the benchmark with source/date/type/confidence'). It misses the 5 anchor because of minor redundancy: 'auditor-runbook.md', 'scoring-semantics.md', and 'roas-benchmark.md' are each listed twice (under 'Runtime Reads' and again under 'Reference Materials'), and cryptic cross-references like 'bare IDs that collide with RAMP/ECHO/TALE' and 'the 59 ceiling' could be tightened. It is well above the 3 anchor since there is no padded or unnecessary explanation. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Mostly executable guidance: an exact runtime-root resolution command, five named veto conditions with verification standards (ROAS-R1 through ROAS-A1), a concrete persistence path pattern 'memory/audits/ad/YYYY-MM-DD-<topic>.md' with 'validate-audit-artifact.py against that intended --relative-path', and worked examples with real numbers ('raw 78, one verified R1 failure: DONE_WITH_CONCERNS/FIX, final 59'). It is not a 5 because key execution details are deferred to external files (the scorer, runbook) and the validator script is referenced but not bundled, leaving minor gaps; it clearly exceeds the 3 anchor's pseudocode-level guidance. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The workflow is clearly sequenced (declare context → normalize currency/windows/IDs/lag → score all 20 items → verify vetoes → run typed scorer → report with exact typed header) with an explicit 'Validation Checkpoints' checklist and a validate→write→revalidate feedback loop in Persistence ('Assemble and validate the complete v3 draft... persist only through one full-content Write, then revalidate the target'). Worked examples cover both success and failure paths, matching the 5 anchor's explicit validation steps and error-recovery loops rather than the 4 anchor's 'minor validation gaps'. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The one bundled reference (references/auditor-runtime.md, a 404-line self-contained runtime) is clearly signaled and one level deep, but most referenced materials are not present in the bundle: '../../../references/auditor-runbook.md', 'scoring-semantics.md', 'roas-benchmark.md', 'runtime-invocation.md', 'measurement-protocol.md', and 'validate-audit-artifact.py' all point outside the skill folder and cannot be verified, and the reference lists are duplicated across two sections. This places it at the 3 anchor (structure present but organization/navigation compromised) rather than 4 (references mostly clear and verifiable) — though it is above 2 since real structure exists and nothing is a monolithic wall of text. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |