Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-engineered instruction-only skill body: a clearly sequenced 8-step procedure with explicit done-when criteria and label enforcement, concrete specs for the UTM taxonomy and self-reported field, and well-signaled one-level references for all detail material. Its weaknesses are noticeable token redundancy — the registry write-path and automation red-line rules are each stated three to four times — and underspecified computation in the decomposition and branded-lift steps.
Suggestions
State the channel-registry write-path rule once (e.g., in the Skill Contract's Writes bullet) and reference it from Procedure step 7 and Save Results instead of repeating the full 'sole writer of memory/channels/' + 'authorized operation: propose' formula three times; do the same for the closed-platform automation red line (currently in the Scope guard, Data Sources, and step 1).
Merge the 'Next Best Skill' section with the Skill Contract's 'Primary next skill' line — they duplicate the same social-measurement-loop handoff — and fold the 'Runtime Reads' list into Reference Materials so owned-community-loop.md is not listed twice.
Add the missing executable details for the two analytical reads: a concrete definition of a deep-URL direct (e.g., sessions landing on URLs longer than N segments or with UTM-less query params) and the lift-comparison method (e.g., a named time-box and baseline window for the GSC branded-query series vs the activity calendar).
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and operational — no space is spent explaining concepts Claude already knows — but there is noticeable redundancy: the registry write-path rule ("sole writer of memory/channels/" / "authorized operation: propose request to registry-events.py") is stated in the Writes bullet, Procedure step 7, and Save Results; the no-automation red line appears three times (Scope guard, Data Sources, step 1); and "Next Best Skill" duplicates the Skill Contract's "Primary next skill". This is more than the "minor instances" of anchor 4 but short of anchor 2's padded sections, since every repetition carries a slightly different operational nuance. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Mostly concrete, executable guidance: a worked UTM taxonomy ("utm_source=<surface>&utm_medium=social-share"), exact field wording ("How did you hear about us?" / 「你是怎么知道我们的?」) with a run-then-code timeline ("run 2-4 weeks, then code recurring answers into a short option list"), named heuristics ("deep-URL directs", "mobile-app skew", "private-push correlation … vs the pre-window baseline"), and a runnable command ("python3 scripts/connectors/pageviews.py"). It stops short of anchor 5 because the two flagship analytical steps leave key details to judgment — what counts as a deep-URL page and how the branded-lift comparison against the activity calendar is computed are unspecified. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | An 8-step ordered procedure (inventory → hygiene spec → field design → decomposition → lift proxy → declare method → route → report) with an explicit completion checklist ("Done when: the method doc names every heuristic with an Estimated/proxy label and a named source … no derived number presented as Measured") and per-step label enforcement ("Label every split Estimated with its heuristic named"). Memory writes are gated ("Do not write memory without asking"), and no destructive or batch operations exist that would trigger the workflow cap; the only missing element, error-recovery feedback loops, has no failure-prone operation to attach to. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The core procedure lives inline where it belongs, and all detail material is pushed to clearly signaled, one-level-deep references annotated with purpose in the Reference Materials section (e.g., "owned-community-loop.md — the owned share-loop spec the instrumentation consumes", "CONNECTORS.md — pageviews.py and the GA4/GSC own-data recipes"). No nested reference chains exist. Minor blemish only: the "Runtime Reads" list repeats owned-community-loop.md already linked twice in the body. (Referenced files sit outside this review copy — ../../../references/… — so their existence could not be verified; scoring reflects the SKILL.md's own structure.) | 5 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |