Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured diagnostic workflow with genuinely strong sequencing and validation logic — the fatigue-vs-saturation split, CVR-truth-set check, and decision gate are concrete and executable. Its weaknesses are repeated boundary/restatement padding across sections and a reference graph that points entirely to files missing from the presented bundle, leaving key templates and thresholds unverifiable.
Suggestions
State the skill's boundaries (not ad-creative-builder, not ad-account-auditor, asks before writing memory) once — in the intro or Skill Contract — and drop the repetitions in step 5, Save Results, Reference Materials, and Next Best Skill.
Include the referenced files (skill-contract.md §Handoff Summary Format and §Save Results Template, measurement-protocol.md frequency ceilings, roas-benchmark.md R1/R2) in the bundle, or inline the minimal versions of the handoff/save templates so the skill is self-contained when the paths don't resolve.
Replace the ellipsis placeholders in the ledger.py record example with one filled example row (realistic frequency/ctr/cvr/reach values) so the command is copy-paste runnable.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The instructions are tight domain guidance with no explanations of concepts Claude already knows, but the same boundary statements are repeated several times — "does not build the replacement creative (`ad-creative-builder` owns that) and does not compute the RQS" (intro), "Only `ad-account-auditor` computes the RQS or runs vetoes" (Reference Materials), "this skill flags; it does not score or veto" (step 5, repeated in Next Best Skill), and "This skill asks before writing memory" (Save Results) — plus the intro paragraph restating the frontmatter description and the Skill Contract's Expected output duplicating step 6. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Gives a concrete executable command with its argument shape (`python3 "${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/scripts/connectors/ledger.py" record <ad-set> --source paid --data '{...}'` plus the `trend` invocation), an exact memory path and filename convention (`memory/ad/fatigue-frequency-manager/YYYY-MM-DD-<ad-set>-fatigue.md`), an explicit per-ad-set output field list, and precise stop-and-ask conditions. Not 5: the ledger example uses ellipsis placeholders rather than a filled runnable sample, and both output templates (handoff summary, save-results) are deferred to external files instead of shown. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Six clearly sequenced steps with explicit validation checkpoints: stop if the set is still in learning phase (step 1), verify a CVR drop against the GA4/ecommerce order truth set before calling it saturation (step 5), a Decision Gate enumerating exact stop-and-ask vs continue-silently conditions, and a "Done when" checklist with routing on failed validation (flag → ad-account-auditor). Not 4: the checkpoints are explicit and outcome-routed, not merely present. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Sections are well organized and each reference is clearly signaled with a description of what it holds, but every referenced file — skill-contract.md, measurement-protocol.md, roas-benchmark.md, CONNECTORS.md, SECURITY.md, scripts/connectors/README.md, and the sibling SKILL.mds — is absent from the bundle (no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories exist, and the ../../../ paths resolve to files that do not exist), so the deferred content (handoff format, save template, frequency ceilings, R1/R2 veto definitions) is unreachable. Not 4 because references cannot be considered 'mostly clear' when none of them resolve; not 2 because the body itself is well-sectioned and references are prominently labeled, not buried. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |