Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a disciplined, terse procedural contract with concrete commands, explicit item/veto IDs, worked examples, and a validation checklist — genuinely actionable for an instruction-only skill. Its main weakness is the reference layer: most cited files are not shipped in this bundle, paths mix two different roots, and several references are duplicated, leaving standalone navigation confused despite the well-designed fail-closed fallback file.
Suggestions
Ship or inline the minimum content of the missing runtime references (especially runtime-invocation.md and the typed conversation header from auditor-runbook.md) so the scoring path is executable in a standalone install, or state plainly in each section which content is repo-install-only.
Consolidate the duplicated reference listings (auditor-runbook.md, scoring-semantics.md, ramp-benchmark.md appear in both Runtime Reads and Reference Materials) into a single clearly-signaled reference section, and clarify the two path bases (`../../../references/` vs `references/`).
Add a compact example of the `<run.json>` structure the scorer command expects (or point to the exact section of auditor-runtime.md that defines it), since that is the one concrete input format the body never shows.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and policy-specific with no explanation of concepts Claude already knows, but run-on generated blocks ("Require the scorer, validator and typed catalogs. If unavailable, collect the selected profile's typed observations and Unknowns...") and mild redundancy across Skill Contract, Instructions, and Validation Checkpoints could be tightened. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable elements are present — `python3 "$AARON_SKILLS_ROOT/scripts/rubric-score.py" score <run.json>`, `validate-audit-artifact.py`, explicit item ranges (R1–R10, A1–A10, M1–M10, P1–P10), veto IDs (RAMP-R1/A1/M1/P1), a worked example with raw scores ("raw 76, one verified A1 failure ... final 59"), and an exact persistence path pattern. The gap is that the `<run.json>` input format and the "exact typed conversation header" are only defined in non-bundled references, so a standalone reader cannot fully execute the scoring path. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The lifecycle sequence is clear — declare profile and evidence window, read runtime sources, collect observations with source/date/type/confidence, run the scorer, verify vetoes, report with typed header — and there is an explicit Validation Checkpoints checklist plus a NOT_SCORED fallback. However, the end-to-end order must be assembled from separate sections rather than one explicit procedure, and error-recovery loops (beyond the scorer-unavailable fallback) are thin, keeping it below the top anchor. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is a genuine overview that delegates detail to reference files, but of the eight referenced paths only `references/auditor-runtime.md` exists in the bundle; the five `../../../references/*.md` files and three cross-skill links are absent here, and three of them (auditor-runbook, scoring-semantics, ramp-benchmark) are listed twice (Runtime Reads and Reference Materials). Mixed path bases and duplicate listings make navigation in this bundle ambiguous rather than clearly signaled. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |