Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A dense, disciplined auditor skill body: lean prose, concrete anchors (env var, path patterns, validator script, veto IDs, worked examples), explicit validation checkpoints and a fail-closed path. Its main weaknesses are the broken reference graph in the standalone bundle — five of six runtime/reference paths don't resolve — plus duplicated reference listings and a procedure spread across oddly numbered sections rather than one ordered flow.
Suggestions
Make the reference graph resolve in the standalone bundle: either bundle the root references (auditor-runbook.md, scoring-semantics.md, echo-benchmark.md, runtime-invocation.md, measurement-protocol.md) under references/ or rewrite all runtime reads to point at the bundled references/auditor-runtime.md, which is the only file that currently exists.
Consolidate the 'Runtime Reads' list and the 'Reference Materials' section into a single reference section to remove the duplicated file listings (auditor-runbook, scoring-semantics, echo-benchmark appear in both).
Present the procedure as one ordered sequence (declare target/profile → read runtime → collect observations → verify vetoes → run scorer → report → persist) and renumber or rename the §2/§3/§5 section headers, which currently appear out of order with no §1 or §4.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and lean with no explanations of concepts Claude already knows, and every section carries operational content. Not 5 because "Runtime Reads" and "Reference Materials" list overlapping files (auditor-runbook.md, scoring-semantics.md, echo-benchmark.md appear in both), and the dense compressed noun-phrases ("channel-truth, claim, disclosure, manipulation, UGC-rights, and denominator checks") duplicate ideas already unpacked elsewhere; not 3 since there is no real padding or over-explanation. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete anchors abound: the exact env-var resolution `AARON_SKILLS_ROOT="${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT:-$(git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>/dev/null || true)}"`, the persistence path pattern `memory/audits/social/YYYY-MM-DD-<topic>.md`, the named validator `validate-audit-artifact.py`, exact item/veto IDs, and worked examples with exact scores. Not 5 because the core instruction "Run the typed scorer" has no inline invocation detail and defers entirely to `runtime-invocation.md`, which does not exist in this bundle; not 3 since most guidance is executable or precisely specified. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Explicit validation is present: a five-item "Validation Checkpoints" section, a fail-closed `score_state: NOT_SCORED` path when the scorer is unavailable, and a validate → single Write → revalidate persistence loop. Not 5 because the procedure is scattered across sections rather than one ordered sequence, and the oddly numbered "§2 ECHO Worked Examples", "§3 ECHO Guardrails", "§5 ECHO Translation" headers (with no §1/§4) disrupt flow; not 3 since checkpoints and error-recovery paths are explicit, not merely implied. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is well-sectioned and references are clearly signaled by name, but scored against the actual bundle, most referenced paths dangle: `../../../references/auditor-runbook.md`, `scoring-semantics.md`, `echo-benchmark.md`, `runtime-invocation.md`, and `measurement-protocol.md` do not exist in this bundle — only `references/auditor-runtime.md` resolves, alongside cross-skill links (`../engagement-inbox-manager/SKILL.md`, etc.) that also don't resolve. Not 4 because one-level-deep navigation is broken for the majority of reads in the standalone install; not 2 because the body itself is well structured and the one bundled runtime file is clearly signaled and used. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |