Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-organized, actionable skill with concrete review/refactoring workflows and real supporting reference files, scoring well on actionability and workflow clarity. Its two real weaknesses are repeated linter/formatter disclaimers that pad the token budget, and a phantom ./reference.md referenced six times that doesn't exist in the bundle, which breaks navigation to the deep content.
Suggestions
Create ./reference.md (or repoint all six citations to existing files) — the Aggregators table, Smells section, and Limitations all link to it for the full heuristic lists and "Scope and attribution" content that exists nowhere in the bundle.
State the "does not replace linter/formatter" caveat once (e.g., in Limitations) and cut it from Overview, When to Use, Best Practices, and Common Pitfalls — it currently consumes ~6 repetitions.
Merge the Aggregators-by-Source table into When to Use or Related Skills to remove the duplicated routing information.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly efficient curated guidance (smells table, tight review steps), but the "does not replace the linter/formatter" caveat is repeated roughly six times (Overview, When to Use, Best Practices ✅/❌, Common Pitfalls, Limitations) and the Aggregators table duplicates When-to-Use and Related-Skills content. Fits anchor 3 (some unnecessary repetition that could be tightened) rather than 2, since each section is individually tight and the padding is one recurring theme. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete guidance throughout: a 5-step review checklist, a copy-pasteable review prompt, an executable before/after Python example, and specific refactor phrasings ("Introduce an interface so this layer does not depend on the concrete DB client"). Anchor 4 (concrete examples with minor gaps) rather than 5 because the core guidance remains judgment heuristics ("SOLID in context") rather than fully executable commands covering the common cases. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Both main workflows are clearly sequenced — "When reviewing code" gives 5 numbered steps ending in a tests/craft check, and "When writing or refactoring" gives 4 steps with the checkpoint "refactor in small steps with tests staying green". Anchor 4 (clear sequence with most checkpoints) rather than 5 because there is no explicit verify-and-recover loop around its own steps; no destructive/batch operations, so the cap-of-3 rule does not apply. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The four real references (references/clean-architecture.md, clean-coder.md, clean-agile.md, design-patterns.md) are clearly signaled one level deep from the Aggregators table and How It Works — but reference.md, cited six times as the holder of "Full lists" and "Scope and attribution", does not exist in the bundle, so the primary deep-dive pointer is dead. This fits anchor 3 (structure present but needs better organization/consistency); it is not anchor 4 because a broken central reference is more than a minor gap. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |