Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is highly actionable and the workflow is sequenced with explicit validation and recovery loops, but token efficiency and file organization lag: a quarter of the content is edge-case protocol detail (conclusions warnings, digest internals, legacy submissions) inlined into an already long single file. Splitting that detail into a reference file and trimming the semantics explanations would lift both weaker dimensions.
Suggestions
Move the edge-case submission semantics (conclusions warning/strict-mode behavior, submission_id/digest fencing, legacy-task retry rules) into a one-level-deep reference file such as references/submission-protocol.md, keeping SKILL.md to the common acknowledge-execute-submit path.
Trim the conclusions paragraph to the essential rule (3-5 one-line entries) and cut the digest-coverage and CoPaw legacy-adoption details unless the worker genuinely must act on them.
Add a short numbered overview (acknowledge → read spec → execute → report progress → submit) near the top so the full sequence is visible before the per-section detail.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly efficient — the guidance is novel protocol detail Claude cannot know, with no generic-concept padding — but roughly 60-80 of the ~260 lines are rare edge-case minutiae that could be tightened or offloaded: the 9-line conclusions-semantics paragraph ("Fewer than 3 comes back as a warning... more than 5 are all recorded in the task meta"), the submission digest internals ("The digest covers your trimmed status, whitespace-collapsed summary..."), and legacy-task handling naming "CoPaw". Not a 4: the over-explanation is more than minor instances; not a 2: the bulk is necessary, non-redundant operational rule. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable: copy-paste-ready JSON payloads for ack_task and submit_task (with status, summary, conclusions, deliverables), the exact status enum (SUCCESS through INTERRUPTED), a concrete progress-note format ("coding-cli:<cli> run=<run_id> dispatched"), and a field-by-field spec for request_attention (kind, question, options, suggested, expiresAt). Not a 4: the common cases are covered by complete, copy-paste examples. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Acknowledge → Read spec → Execute → Submit → Completion sequence is clearly sectioned, with explicit validation checkpoints ("confirm the acknowledgment reached shared storage (`synced: true`)") and error-recovery feedback loops throughout: ack failure → "stop and report the blocker", sync failure → inspect authoritative state and "retry with exactly the same status, summary, and ordered deliverables", and the CLI-run outcome mapping to SUCCESS/PARTIAL/BLOCKED. Not a 4: validation steps and recovery loops are explicit, not implicit. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is well-sectioned with clear headers (Task Directory, Acknowledge, Execute, Submit, Completion Message) but is a single ~260-line monolith with no bundle files or references; the edge-case material (digest semantics, submission identity fencing, legacy-task adoption) is inline content that plausibly belongs in a one-level-deep reference file. Not a 4: content that should be separate is inline and the file exceeds the under-50-lines simple-skill exception; not a 2: structure is clear and navigable, with no buried references. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |