Content
62%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The procedural core is excellent — a well-sequenced five-step workflow with validation gates and genuinely executable shell code — but it is buried in a trust-boundary section that is roughly twice as long as it needs to be, and the skill keeps ~200 lines of protocol inline that belong in bundle files that do not exist here. Tightening the pre-screen prose and moving the shell functions into a real scripts/ directory would lift both weak dimensions.
Suggestions
State each trust-boundary rule once: the checker-discovery logic and the two-line return shape are each explained two to three times (shell comments, prose, and code); keep the code plus one prose statement and cut the repeats.
Move the inline shell library (vocab_checker, span_ok, prescreen_ok, checked_prescreen, checked_outcome) into a scripts/ or references/ file in the bundle and reference it from the body, rather than inlining ~100 lines of shell in SKILL.md.
Resolve or clearly signal the external references (scripts/agents.lib.sh, scripts/vocab.config.sh, scripts/vocab.sh, constitution/local-product.md.template) — none are in this bundle, so a reader cannot tell which are kit-provided versus expected to be missing.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Roughly half the body (the Trust boundary section, ~190 lines) is noticeably verbose: the checker-discovery rule is stated twice (as shell comments at lines 129-132 and again as prose at 207-215), the two-line return shape is described at least three times (106-111, 198-206, and via prescreen_ok), and "fails closed" is restated repeatedly. The information is accurate and novel, but the rubric penalizes verbosity even when accurate, and the same fences could be stated once each. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable guidance throughout: complete shell functions (vocab_checker, span_ok, prescreen_ok, checked_prescreen, checked_outcome), a runnable scratch-directory lifecycle snippet (mktemp, redirect, checked_prescreen, rm -rf), and a specific report location (docs/dogfood-reports/). Minor gaps: the referenced helpers (scripts/agents.lib.sh, scripts/vocab.sh, scripts/vocab.config.sh) are not part of this bundle, and the reader-subagent spawn is left partially adapter-dependent. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five-step procedure is clearly sequenced with explicit validation checkpoints and feedback loops: refuse to run on trunk, stop if the surface will not come up, stop on a red suite, pre-screen output before reading it, checked_outcome gates every row's decision line before the report, and a refused outcome triggers a re-read and re-stamp. Error paths are named and handled throughout. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Section headers give the body reasonable structure, but no bundle files exist while the body references external ones (scripts/vocab.sh, scripts/agents.lib.sh, scripts/vocab.config.sh, constitution/local-product.md.template) that are neither present nor clearly signaled as separate materials. The ~190-line pre-screen protocol with inline shell libraries is content that clearly belongs in a separate scripts/ or references/ file, which anchors this at 'some structure but could be better organized'. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |