Content
66%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers genuinely strong workflow design: a sequenced 9-step process, explicit input validation with a feedback loop, and a mandatory structured output template that functions as a checklist. Its main weakness is severe redundancy — the clarify-first rule, evidence-level taxonomy, overclaim patterns, and hard rules each appear three to four times, including near-verbatim duplication of references/hard-rules.md — which inflates token cost without adding guidance value.
Suggestions
Remove the inline "Hard Rules" section (10 items) — it restates references/hard-rules.md almost verbatim; keep a one-line pointer plus the 2-3 rules that must be enforced before any output is produced.
Merge the overlapping framing sections — "Task", "Core Function", "Scope Boundary", "What This Skill Should Not Do", and "Quality Standard" each restate the same scope and failure modes — into a single compact purpose-and-boundaries section.
State the evidence-level taxonomy and overclaim-pattern taxonomy once (in the existing reference files or once in the body) and drop the duplicated lists in "Important Distinctions", Step 3, and Step 4.
Add one worked before/after example — an inflated claim paired with its evidence-anchored rewrite — to make the calibration guidance concrete for the most common case.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The same instructions repeat many times across sections: the clarify-first rule appears in Reference Module Integration, Input Validation, Step 1, Hard Rule 10, and output section H; the evidence-level taxonomy appears in Task, Important Distinctions, Step 3, and again in references/evidence-level-mapping-rules.md; "Core Function" restates "Task"; and the 10-item "Hard Rules" section restates references/hard-rules.md nearly verbatim. This matches anchor 2 (noticeably verbose, several padded sections) rather than 3, since the redundancy is pervasive rather than a few spots that could be tightened. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | For an instruction-only skill, the guidance is concrete and executable: a 9-step procedure, a defined evidence-level taxonomy, named overclaim patterns, severity classes, 10 hard rules, and a mandatory A-H output structure. It falls short of anchor 5 only because there is no worked example (an inflated claim rewritten into calibrated wording) covering the common cases. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Execution section gives a clear numbered 9-step sequence with an explicit input-sufficiency validation checkpoint (Step 1 plus output section A "Input Match Check"), a genuine feedback loop (ask for missing manuscript/study context before producing a full review, echoed in section H), and a checklist via the mandatory A-H output structure. This matches anchor 5 (explicit validation steps, feedback loops, checklists); the workflow is not a destructive or batch operation, so no validation cap applies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | All 7 referenced files exist, are one level deep, and each is annotated in the body with when and how to use it — references are clearly signaled, not buried. However, the body inlines substantial content that duplicates the reference files (hard rules, evidence levels, overclaim patterns, severity classes), which is a real organization gap; this fits anchor 4 (good structure, most content appropriately placed, minor gaps) rather than 5. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |