Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, highly actionable instruction skill with a clear 8-step workflow, explicit guided-focusing feedback loops, and a real one-level-deep reference bundle. Its main weaknesses are meaningful redundancy across sections and a section-lettering mismatch between output-section-guidance.md and the body's mandatory A-K structure, which together cost it on conciseness and workflow clarity.
Suggestions
Deduplicate the body: remove the inline "Supported Question Types" list (it duplicates references/question-type-taxonomy.md), merge the Interactive Refinement Rule into the Guided Focusing Mode section, and collapse the Downstream Routing Standard into Step 8 / Section J — this alone would cut the body substantially.
Fix the section-lettering mismatch: references/output-section-guidance.md defines only Sections A-J with letters offset from the body's mandatory A-K structure (e.g., its Section D is framing rationale while the body's Section D is guided focusing). Realign it to A-K or switch both to unambiguous section names.
Add one worked example (a vague input mapped to a filled-in A-K output) to lift actionability from mostly-executable to copy-paste-ready, and trim abstract quality statements like "reveal the real question behind the vague prompt" in favor of concrete checks.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~330-line body is mostly efficient and does not explain concepts Claude already knows, but contains notable redundancy that could be tightened: the question-type list is duplicated between the body's "Supported Question Types" and references/question-type-taxonomy.md; guided focusing is described three times (Guided Focusing Mode, Decision Logic Step 4, Interactive Refinement Rule); downstream routing appears in the Downstream Routing Standard, Step 8, and Section J; and the "do not answer the question" rule is restated four times. It is above a 2 because the padding is repetition rather than educational filler, but below a 4 because several sections restate one another. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | For an instruction-only skill the guidance is largely executable: a mandatory A-K output structure with per-section content requirements, an exact table header for Section F, a verbatim out-of-scope redirect template, explicit framework-to-question-type mappings, and concrete limits ("2-5 concise, high-yield narrowing questions", question ordering, stopping rules). It falls short of a 5 because there is no worked example showing a completed A-K output, and some guidance such as the Quality Standard ("reveal the real question behind the vague prompt") remains abstract. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 8-step Decision Logic is clearly sequenced with each step tied to a reference module, and the guided-focusing loop has explicit entry conditions, question ordering, and stop rules; out-of-scope input has a validate-and-stop redirect. However, references/output-section-guidance.md defines sections A-J whose lettering is offset from the body's A-K structure (its Section D covers framing rationale while the body's Section D is guided focusing questions), so the instruction to use that file "as the section-level formatting and content control standard for Sections A-K" is internally inconsistent — a real validation gap that keeps this below 5. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle structure is genuinely good: all ten files referenced in the body exist in references/, are one level deep, and each is explicitly mapped to a specific output section with a "use when" signal. Two minor gaps hold it below 5: the question-type taxonomy content is duplicated inline in the body rather than left in its reference file, and output-section-guidance.md's misaligned A-J lettering breaks navigation for that one reference. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |