Content
48%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill body delivers a genuinely executable core — a documented CLI matching the real script and a clearly chained three-prompt workflow — but wraps it in ~80 lines of generic templated boilerplate, duplicated sections, and fabricated validation/output expectations that contradict the script's actual behavior. The useful content is accurate; the packaging around it is not.
Suggestions
Delete the templated filler sections ("Key Features", "Dependencies", "Output Contract", "Recommended Workflow", "Deterministic Output Rules", "Completion Checklist", and similar generic process rules) and merge the duplicated Usage/Validation sections into one of each.
Fix the fabricated "Quick Validation" expected output and the "expert_interview_topics_result.md" claim to match the script's actual stdout-only, three-prompt output.
Correct the broken "See `## Usage` above" reference (the Usage section appears after it) by restructuring into a single ordered document: What it does → Command → Output → Example → When not to use.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Roughly half of the ~160-line body is templated boilerplate that adds nothing skill-specific — "Use this skill when the request matches its documented task boundary", "Key Features", "Dependencies", "Output Contract", "Recommended Workflow", "Failure Handling", "Deterministic Output Rules", "Completion Checklist" — all of which restate process discipline Claude already applies. There is also a broken self-reference: "See `## Usage` above for related details" (line 28) points to a section defined later in the document (line 64). This matches anchor 2 (noticeably verbose, several padded sections); it is worse than 3 because the filler is pervasive rather than occasional. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The core guidance is concrete and executable — `python scripts/main.py --topic "<topic>" --background "<expert_background>" [--file "<path>"]` with documented arguments, a runnable example, and an accurate description of the three output prompts and their placeholders. However, "Quick Validation" fabricates an expected `--help` output ("Result file: expert_interview_topics_result.md / Validation summary: PASS/FAIL / Assumptions") that argparse never produces, and the "Output Contract" recommends a deterministic result file the prompt-only script never writes — internal contradictions a reader cannot execute against. Fits anchor 3 (concrete guidance but incomplete/with key inaccuracies); not 4 because the fabricated validation output materially misleads. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The real workflow is explicitly sequenced: the script emits Step 1 (title generation prompt, ready to use), Step 2 (selection prompt with a `{generated_titles}` placeholder to fill from Step 1), and Step 3 (question prompt with `{selected_title}` from Step 2), and the doc explains the chaining and the optional transcript file. Pre-run checks (`python -m py_compile`, `--help`, `validate_skill.py`) are present. Fits anchor 4 (clear sequence, most checkpoints present, minor validation gaps); not 5 because there are no error-recovery feedback loops and the validation steps are superficial. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Bundle references are real and accurate (`scripts/main.py`, `scripts/validate_skill.py` both exist and match the documented interface), and the bulky prompt templates correctly live in the script rather than inlined in SKILL.md. But the document itself is poorly organized: duplicated sections ("## Usage" vs "## Example Usage", "## Validation Shortcut" vs "## Quick Validation"), two competing top-level narratives, and the broken "See `## Usage` above" cross-reference. Fits anchor 3 (some structure but could be better organized); not 4 because the duplication and broken navigation are more than minor gaps. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |