Content
46%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The journal-specific core (output table format, inputs, tier definitions) is solid, but it is buried under ~60 lines of generic boilerplate that applies to any skill. The script dependency is named but never demonstrated on real input, and the expected validation output is inaccurate. The result is a skill that tells Claude what to produce more clearly than how to produce it.
Suggestions
Cut the boilerplate sections (When to Use / When Not to Use / Required Inputs / Output Contract / Failure Handling / User Checkpoints) down to the few rules that actually apply to journal recommendation, reclaiming the token budget.
Show an executable invocation of `python scripts/journal_ranker.py` with real journal text and expected sorted output, and bundle or reference an actual CAS warning-list data file so the exclusion rule is actionable.
Fix the Quick Validation expected output to match what `journal_ranker.py --help` actually prints, and specify at which workflow step the sorting script runs.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Roughly half the body is generic template boilerplate — "Use this skill when the request matches its documented task boundary", "Do not use this skill when the required source data, identifiers, files, or credentials are missing", and the Output Contract / Failure Handling / User Checkpoints blocks — that adds no journal-specific information. This matches anchor 2: several padded sections. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The output table template with a filled example row and the explicit inputs list are concrete, but there is no executable example of running journal_ranker.py on real input (only --help), the mandated CAS warning list has no bundled data source, and the assessment step is abstract ("Extract keywords and determine the specific research field"). Anchor 3: some concrete guidance but missing key details. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A real sequence exists (Assess Manuscript → Recommend Journals, plus quality rules and a Quick Validation step), but the Quick Validation's "Expected output format" ("Result file: journal_recommender_result.md...") does not match what `--help` would actually print, and where the sorting script fits in the actual generation workflow is never specified. Anchor 3: steps listed but checkpoints flawed/implicit. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Single SKILL.md with clearly signaled sections and one verified one-level-deep bundle reference (`scripts/journal_ranker.py`, which exists). Two organization gaps keep it from anchor 5: the CAS warning list the skill depends on is not bundled or referenced as a file, and the Output Format section oddly precedes the document title and Overview. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |