Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers a clear, well-sequenced workflow with explicit validation checkpoints at both ends and correctly referenced, existing one-level-deep bundle files. Its main weakness is verbosity — roughly a third of the sections are generic boilerplate or redundant restatements — plus minor inconsistencies (conflicting output filenames, a placeholder pdf-extract command) that slightly dilute actionability.
Suggestions
Cut the generic boilerplate sections (Required Inputs, Quick Validation, User Checkpoints, Input Validation) that merely restate Validation and Safety Rules, and state each rule once — e.g., the "write 'Not specified', never fabricate" rule is repeated three times and can live only in Step 6; this directly targets the conciseness score.
Resolve the conflicting output filenames: the example shows "outputs/paper_close_reading.md" while Steps 7 and the Output Contract mandate "outputs/literature_close_read_result.md" — pick one deterministic name and use it everywhere to close the actionability gap.
Either specify the pdf-extract dependency version and a real conversion command, or drop the Dependencies section and the placeholder "pdf-extract paper.pdf > paper.md" example that is flagged as depending on the local installation.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is noticeably padded with generic boilerplate sections that add no skill-specific value: "Required Inputs" ("A clearly specified task goal aligned with the documented scope", "All required files, identifiers, parameters, or environment variables before execution"), "Quick Validation" ("No local script validation step is required for this skill"), "User Checkpoints", and "Input Validation" largely duplicate "Validation and Safety Rules" and "When Not to Use". The same rules are also restated within the workflow ("Not specified" — never fabricate appears in Steps 3 and 6 and again in Implementation Details; the UTF-8/valid-Markdown requirement appears three times). Not a 1 because it never explains concepts Claude already knows and the core workflow content is on-topic; more than a 3 because at least four sections are template filler rather than a single instance of over-explanation. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The guidance is mostly concrete and directly followable: "Use `assets/deep_reading_template.md` as your output structure", "Save to `outputs/literature_close_read_result.md`", and an explicit fallback rule ("If any field is not explicitly stated, write 'Not specified' — do NOT infer"). Minor gaps keep it from a 5: the example command "pdf-extract paper.pdf > paper.md" is a placeholder ("exact command/options depend on your local pdf-extract installation"), the dependency is listed as "version: not specified", and the example output name "outputs/paper_close_reading.md" conflicts with the mandated "literature_close_read_result.md". It is above a 3 because these are detail-level gaps, not missing key steps — the 7-step instruction path is specific and executable as written. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear 7-step sequence runs from "Step 1: Validate Input" ("Confirm the user has provided the paper content") through "Step 7: Quality Check" ("Verify every claim traces back to explicit paper content"), with a Failure Handling section covering recovery. Not a 5 because there is no explicit loop-back instruction when the Step 7 quality check fails (the feedback loop is only implicit via Failure Handling), and the validation checkpoints, while present at both ends, do not include intermediate checkpoints. Not a 3 because validation is explicit rather than absent or merely implicit, and the sequence has no gaps. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body cleanly signals two one-level-deep references that both exist in the bundle — "Requirements/checklist: `references/guide.md`" and "Output template: `assets/deep_reading_template.md`" — repeated under "Files used" and inside the relevant workflow steps, making navigation easy. Not a 5 because content is not optimally split: the body inlines much of what guide.md already contains (input/output checklists, quality checks, format rules), creating duplication between SKILL.md and the reference rather than a lean overview pointing to details. Not a 3 because references are clearly signaled, shallow, and well organized. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |