Content
53%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill has a genuinely good progressive-disclosure structure (real, well-labeled reference and template files) and concrete, mostly executable output contracts. It is dragged down by substantial generic boilerplate sections and internal contradictions (direct-output vs. user checkpoints; Markdown-only input vs. PMID/PDF/CSV/DOCX inputs) that pad the body and blur the workflow.
Suggestions
Delete or rewrite the generic boilerplate sections (Required Inputs, Output Contract, Failure Handling, User Checkpoints, Input Validation, Quick Validation) with skill-specific content — the fixed outputs, input assumption, and validation checks are already stated elsewhere in the body or in references/guide.md.
Resolve the contradictory directives: pick one policy on user confirmation ("Output must be produced directly (no confirmation steps)" vs. "User Checkpoints"), and align the Required Inputs table with the Markdown-only input assumption instead of listing PMID/PDF/CSV/DOCX.
State the output file naming, encoding, and language rules once (in a single Outputs section or solely in references/guide.md) instead of repeating them across Example Usage, Implementation Details, and the guide, and add one worked example of a filled table row plus a definition of how the Paper Abbreviation is derived.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Noticeably verbose with several padded sections: generic boilerplate ("Required Inputs" table listing "PMID, PDF, CSV, DOCX", "Output Contract: Structured result or target file aligned with this skill's objective", "Failure Handling", "User Checkpoints", "Input Validation", "Quick Validation") carries no skill-specific information, and the output filenames/encoding/language rules are repeated three times across "Example Usage → Steps", "Implementation Details → Paths and naming", and again in references/guide.md. This matches anchor 2 (several unnecessary explanations or padded sections) better than anchor 3. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Mostly executable guidance: exact output paths ("outputs/{Paper Abbreviation}-experiment-summary.md", "-models.csv", "-methods.csv", "-biomarkers.csv"), explicit pointers to real bundle files with their purpose ("Extraction rules and evidence requirements: references/guide.md", "Output template: assets/template.md"), and a concrete extraction sequence. Minor gaps keep it below anchor 5: no worked example of a filled output row, and how the "Paper Abbreviation" is derived is never specified. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence is listed (open the Markdown → extract models/methods/biomarkers page by page → follow guide.md and template.md → output exactly 4 files) and validation sections exist, but written directives contradict each other: "Output must be produced directly (no confirmation steps or optional branches)" vs "User Checkpoints" demanding confirmation before multi-stage generation; and a Markdown-only input assumption ("paper content is available as Markdown") vs a Required Inputs table accepting "PMID, PDF, CSV, DOCX". These incoherences leave it at anchor 3 (steps present, checkpoints undermined) rather than 4. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle structure is clean and one level deep: rules live in references/guide.md and the output structure in assets/template.md — both real files, clearly signaled with their purpose in "Key Features" and "Steps". The minor gap versus anchor 5 is that naming/encoding/language rules are duplicated inline in the body instead of being left solely to the reference, adding redundant content to the overview. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |