Content
42%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The domain core is strong — data-format tables, an exact Rscript invocation with parameters, and a concrete output template — but it is buried in generic template filler and undermined by documentation that does not match the actual scripts (no real --help, fabricated expected output, unexplained fallback role and its Binary-only limit). The single-file structure with real bundle scripts is acceptable, though the redundant sections and broken internal references hurt navigation.
Suggestions
Delete the generic boilerplate sections (When to Use, Key Features, Dependencies, Implementation Details, Required Inputs, Output Contract, Validation and Safety Rules, Failure Handling) — they contain no task-specific information and roughly halve the token cost.
Fix the fallback-script documentation: state that it is used when R is unavailable, that it supports Binary data only, and replace the fabricated '--help expected output' with the actual usage string from the script.
Resolve the internal inconsistency: 'See ## Workflow above' points to a section that appears later, and 'Example run plan'/'Quick Validation' duplicate or contradict the Workflow — collapse them into one execution path.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Roughly half the body is generic template boilerplate that adds no domain information: "Use this skill when the request matches its documented task boundary", "Dependencies: not explicitly version-pinned in this skill package", "Output discipline: keep results reproducible", plus near-duplicate run plans ("Example run plan" vs "## Workflow") and a time-stamped cd path ("cd 20260316/scientific-skills/..."). That is several padded sections of content Claude already knows — squarely the 2 anchor (noticeably verbose), and not 3 because the padding is extensive rather than occasional. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The core path is genuinely executable: "Rscript scripts/baujat_plot.R \"<csv_path>\" \"<type>\" \"<outcome_name>\" \"<output_dir>\"" with parameter descriptions, backed by real bundle scripts and concrete data-format tables. But the documented fallback usage is inaccurate — the script has no argparse/--help, so "python scripts/baujat_plot_fallback.py --help" just prints a one-line usage string and exits 1, while the body's "Expected output format" ("Result file: meta_baujat_plot_result.md...") is fabricated and matches nothing the script produces; the fallback's Binary-only limitation is also undocumented. That mix of concrete commands with fabricated/incomplete details fits 3 (some concrete guidance but incomplete), not 4. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Workflow section has a real sequence with a validation checkpoint ("Validate data integrity (at least 3 studies are required...)" → exact Rscript command → output template), which exceeds the 2 anchor. But clarity is undercut by two execution paths (R script vs. Python fallback) whose relationship is never explained, an incoherent self-reference ("See `## Workflow` above" in Implementation Details points to a section that appears later), and a "Quick Validation" step that doesn't connect to the workflow. Those gaps — present sequence but missing/incoherent checkpoints — fit 3 rather than 4. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle structure is legitimate: both referenced script paths ("scripts/baujat_plot_fallback.py", "scripts/baujat_plot.R") exist and are clearly signaled, with no nested references. However, everything lives inline in one ~220-line SKILL.md with no reference files, and the generic boilerplate sections (Dependencies, Output Contract, Validation and Safety Rules, Failure Handling) are content that belongs either trimmed or split out; the broken "See Workflow above" pointer also hinders navigation. That places it at 3 — some structure but could be better organized — rather than 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 11 / 20 Passed |