Content
48%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill has a clear purpose, real validation commands, and a genuine one-level-deep reference, but the body is bloated with roughly ten overlapping governance sections and boilerplate checklists that crowd out concrete guidance. The core extraction procedure itself is described only abstractly, with no runnable invocation of scripts/main.py or sample output.
Suggestions
Consolidate the redundant governance sections (Error Handling, Failure Handling, When Not to Use, Input Validation, User Checkpoints, Output Requirements, Output Contract, Response Template) into a single compact section; delete or move the Risk Assessment, Security Checklist, Lifecycle Status, and Evaluation Criteria boilerplate to a reference file.
Add an executable invocation of the core functionality, e.g. a real command like `python scripts/main.py --paper-ids ... --method-type "Western Blot"` plus a short sample of the structured output format.
Move the audit commands and fallback boundary detail (already duplicated in references/audit-reference.md) out of the main body to eliminate duplication and shrink the overview.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is noticeably verbose: Error Handling, Failure Handling, When Not to Use, Input Validation, User Checkpoints, Output Requirements, Output Contract, and Response Template repeat the same missing-input/stop/partial-output guidance, and Risk Assessment, Security Checklist, Lifecycle Status, and Evaluation Criteria are boilerplate padding unrelated to the extraction task. It stays above anchor 1 only because it never explains concepts Claude already knows. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete audit commands exist ("python -m py_compile scripts/main.py", "python scripts/main.py --help") along with Parameters, Returns, and a brief Example, but the core extraction task itself is never given an executable invocation (no real scripts/main.py call with paper_ids and method_type) and no sample of the structured output format. This is 'some concrete guidance but incomplete' rather than mostly-executable anchor 4. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five-step Workflow is sequenced with explicit checkpoints ("Validate that the request matches the documented scope and stop early", fallback on failure, Quick Validation section, User Checkpoints before batch operations), so the batch-operation validation cap at 3 does not apply. It falls short of anchor 5 because key steps like "Use the packaged script path or the documented reasoning path" remain abstract rather than command-backed, and there is no validate-fix-retry loop for the extraction output itself. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The single reference (references/audit-reference.md) is real, clearly signaled in a References section, and one level deep with no nesting, but the SKILL.md body inlines large generic compliance content (risk table, security checklist, lifecycle status, evaluation criteria) that belongs in a separate reference file. This is anchor 3 (some structure, content that should be separate is inline) rather than 4, where organization gaps are only minor. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |