Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is structurally excellent — a fixed execution sequence with a mandatory dependency check, a fully specified output template, and an exemplary one-level-deep reference mapping — but it is heavily padded: the same rules (fabrication ban, disclaimer placement, risk review, should-nots, DESeq2/limma) are each restated three to four times across sections. Consolidating the duplicated blocks would cut the file by roughly a third with no loss of operational content.
Suggestions
Consolidate the three copies of the self-critical risk-review checklist (Step 7, Section L, and Hard Rule 13) into a single definition, referenced by the other two.
State each hard rule once: fold the DESeq2/limma rule, the Dataset Disclaimer placement rule, and the fabrication ban into the Hard Rules section alone, removing their duplicates in Formatting Expectations, Step 6, Section H, Step 4.5, and Core Function.
Merge 'Sample Triggers' into the Input Validation examples and fold 'What This Skill Should Not Do' into the Core Function 'should not' list, removing two near-duplicate sections.
Include the actual Dataset Disclaimer template inline (or a one-line pointer to where it is defined in references/dataset-recommendation-and-disclaimer.md), since the body mandates it repeatedly without ever showing it.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is noticeably padded through wholesale repetition rather than concept over-explanation: the risk-review checklist appears three times (Step 7, Section L, Hard Rule 13); the fabrication ban appears in the frontmatter, Step 4.5, Core Function, and Hard Rule 1; the Dataset Disclaimer placement rule is stated in Step 6, Section H, and Hard Rule 2; the DESeq2/limma rule is stated twice (Formatting Expectations and Hard Rule 7); 'Sample Triggers' largely duplicates the Input Validation examples; and 'What This Skill Should Not Do' duplicates 'Core Function should not'. This matches 'several unnecessary explanations or padded sections'; it is not 3 because the redundancy is systemic (~40% of the body could be cut) rather than occasional tightening, and not 1 because nothing explains concepts Claude already knows and all content is operational. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | For an instruction-only skill the guidance is mostly executable: a fixed 7-step execution order, a mandatory A-L output structure with per-section content specs (including exact table columns for Sections C and F), a copy-paste redirect template, and concrete method defaults ('count data → DESeq2 (recommended default)', 'non-count normalized data → limma'). It is not 5 because some key artifacts are named but never shown inline — the 'mandatory Dataset Disclaimer' text itself is never provided in SKILL.md, and no example output section or filled-in configuration table is given; it is not 3 because the guidance is specific and complete enough to execute without guessing at structure. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 7 steps run in explicit order ('always run in order') and include a genuine pre-output checkpoint: 'Step 5 — Dependency Consistency Check (mandatory before output)' with a five-point checklist, plus a closing risk review in Step 7. This matches 'clear sequence with most checkpoints present'; it is not 5 because Step 5 specifies no remediation loop (what to do when the consistency check fails, or re-checking after fixes) and the dependency check is stated once without a verify-fix-revalidate cycle, and it is not 3 because the checkpoints are explicit and detailed rather than implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The 'Reference Module Integration' section maps each of the nine reference files to the exact output section where it must be used ('references/study-patterns.md → use when selecting the dominant clinical–multi-omics study pattern in Section B', etc.), all nine referenced paths exist in the references/ directory, references are one level deep, and details (method library, dataset disclaimer text, validation hierarchy, figure plan) are appropriately split out of the overview. This matches the anchor for a clear overview with well-signaled one-level-deep references and easy navigation. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |