Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, genuinely actionable instruction skill with a clear ordered workflow, decision bands, and self-audit. Its weaknesses are internal redundancy (steps vs. output sections vs. hard rules) and a bundle where a majority of reference files are orphaned or duplicated relative to what SKILL.md signals.
Suggestions
Remove or merge the 9 orphaned reference files (or link them explicitly), especially the near-duplicates like novelty-assessment-framework.md, decision-band-rules.md, and literature-integrity-rules.md, so every bundled file is reachable and unambiguous.
Consolidate the Mandatory Output Structure with the 8 execution steps (e.g., annotate each step with its output section) and trim Hard Rules / "What This Skill Should Not Do" overlap to a single list.
Add one short worked example (a compressed sample assessment ending in a decision band) to make the expected output concrete.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly efficient — the body teaches domain-specific judgment standards Claude does not already know — but it duplicates itself: the 11-section Mandatory Output Structure largely restates Steps 2–7, Hard Rules overlap "What This Skill Should Not Do" and the referenced frameworks (e.g., pseudo-novelty flags appear in Step 2 and again as Hard Rule 7), and the Reference Module Integration bullets restate in-step references. It is not 2 because there is no generic padding or explanation of concepts Claude already knows. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable instruction-only guidance: 8 ordered steps each with explicit sub-items, five named decision bands, a copy-paste redirect message for out-of-scope requests, and 11 mandatory output sections. It is not 5 because there is no worked example showing what a high-quality assessment output looks like, and some judgments (e.g., "Flag pseudo-novelty aggressively") depend entirely on referenced frameworks without inline anchors. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear fixed sequence ("8 Steps (always run in order)") with checkpoints: Step 1 forces restatement of vague proposals with explicit assumptions, Step 8 is a pre-finalization self-critical audit, and Step 7 requires justifying the chosen band against the nearest alternative. It is not 5 because there is no explicit feedback loop (e.g., "if the Step 8 audit invalidates the band, revisit Step 7") — the audit is a checkpoint, not a retry path. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body's five referenced files all exist, are one level deep, and each carries explicit "Use for..." signals — good practice. However, the actual bundle contains 14 reference files and 9 are never linked from SKILL.md, including apparent near-duplicates (novelty-assessment-framework.md vs novelty-audit-framework.md, decision-band-rules.md vs start-decision-bands.md, literature-integrity-rules.md vs literature-and-resource-integrity-rules.md), leaving over half the bundle undiscoverable and ambiguous about which file is authoritative. It is not 4 because this goes beyond minor organization gaps. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |