Content
42%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is dominated by duplicated generic boilerplate rather than the skill's actual domain workflow, and its most concrete-looking code examples do not match the bundled script's real API or file paths, so a user following them hits errors. The single reference is properly linked but thin, and the promising domain-specific sections (journal search, predatory checks) are undermined by non-executable examples.
Suggestions
Fix the code examples to match the actual bundled script: scripts/main.py provides OpenAccessScout.search_open_access(doi, title, authors) and a --doi/--title/--authors/--list-sources CLI — replace find_journals, assess_journal, compare_apc, the `scripts.oa_scout` import, and the `scripts/oa_scout.py --search ... --max-apc` command with real usage, or implement those methods in the script.
Cut the duplicated boilerplate: merge Error Handling with Failure Handling and Output Requirements with Output Contract/Response Template into one short section each, and remove the pasted description from the When to Use bullet — this would remove well over half the body's tokens without losing domain information.
Rework the Workflow into the concrete domain sequence (run the quick check, search for OA versions, review source/license results, apply the predatory warning-signs list, report with assumptions and limits) with the py_compile and fallback checkpoints attached to specific steps instead of abstract meta-steps.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Roughly two-thirds of the 189-line body is generic process boilerplate ("Output Requirements", "Error Handling", "Input Validation", "Response Template", "When Not to Use", "Required Inputs", "Output Contract", "Failure Handling", "User Checkpoints", "Quick Validation") with heavy duplication — Error Handling vs Failure Handling and Output Requirements vs Output Contract vs Response Template repeat the same guidance. The "When to Use" bullet also awkwardly pastes the description ("the task needs Use when finding open access journals..."), matching the noticeably-verbose anchor with several padded sections. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The Quick Start and Core Capabilities code blocks look copy-paste ready but are fabricated against the actual bundle: scripts/main.py exposes only search_open_access(doi, title, authors), print_results, and a --list-sources/--doi/--title/--authors CLI, not find_journals, search(keywords, filters), assess_journal, or compare_apc. The import path `from scripts.oa_scout import ...` and CLI `python scripts/oa_scout.py --search ... --max-apc 2000` reference a nonexistent file and undefined flags, so the concrete-looking guidance is not executable as written — matching the incomplete-guidance anchor rather than the mostly-executable anchor. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Workflow section lists a sequence with a fallback step and the Quick Check (py_compile) provides a pre-execution checkpoint, but the five steps are abstract meta-process ("Confirm the user objective...", "Return a structured result...") rather than the concrete domain workflow (search journals, assess publisher, compare APC), and no step ties to an actual runnable command from the bundled script. The sequence is present but checkpoints are implicit and disconnected from real operations; the destructive/batch cap does not apply since this skill is neither. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The one bundled reference (references/audit-reference.md) is real, one level deep, and clearly signaled in a References section, but it only restates scope and audit commands. Meanwhile a large volume of generic policy content that belongs in a reference (or nowhere) is inlined in SKILL.md, and body references to scripts/oa_scout.py / scripts.oa_scout point to files that do not exist in the bundle, weakening navigation. This sits between the some-structure and good-structure anchors. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 11 / 20 Passed |