Content
52%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill's core assessment workflow is well structured with a clear domain sequence, explicit synthesis rules, and a concrete JSON output contract, and its reference file and scripts genuinely exist. The main weaknesses are a large tail of generic, self-duplicating template sections that consume tokens without skill-specific value, and helper-script documentation that is inaccurate versus the actual scripts (missing required argument, wrong output filename).
Suggestions
Cut or merge the generic tail sections (When to Use, When Not to Use, Required Inputs, Output Contract, Failure Handling, User Checkpoints, Input Validation, Quick Validation) into a short, single section, keeping only ROB2-specific guidance; the missing-input rule is currently repeated in at least four places.
Correct the PDF extraction instructions to match the script: show `python scripts/extract_pdf.py paper.pdf` (the path argument is required) and fix the documented output to `<stem>_fulltext.txt` rather than `full_text.txt`; also use the `scripts/` prefix consistently for both helper scripts.
Embed validation as an explicit checkpoint in the workflow (e.g., after synthesizing the overall judgement, verify all five domain fields and Overall are set and consistent with the High/Some-concerns/Low rules before emitting the JSON) instead of leaving it only in a trailing checklist.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The core sections (Usage, Workflow Steps, Output Format, Helper Scripts) are tight, but roughly 40% of the body is generic template boilerplate ("When to Use", "When Not to Use", "Required Inputs", "Output Contract", "Failure Handling", "User Checkpoints", "Input Validation", "Quick Validation") that is not specific to ROB2 and duplicates itself (e.g., the missing-input rule appears in at least four sections). This is noticeably verbose with several padded sections — anchor 2 — rather than mostly efficient with only some trimmable explanation (anchor 3). | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The JSON output contract and domain workflow steps are concrete, but the helper-script guidance is not executable as written: the body shows `python extract_pdf.py` with no arguments, while the actual script requires a PDF path argument and writes to `<stem>_fulltext.txt`, not the documented `full_text.txt`. That is concrete guidance with missing/incorrect key details — anchor 3 — rather than mostly executable guidance with only minor gaps (anchor 4). | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence is clear: extract study info, assess the five named domains, synthesize via explicit High/Some-concerns/Low rules, output to a specified JSON schema, with a separate Quick Validation section and failure-handling guidance. It falls short of anchor 5 because validation is a trailing checklist rather than embedded checkpoints with an explicit validate → fix → re-validate feedback loop, and phrases like "assesses each of the 5 ROB2 domains in parallel (conceptually) or sequentially" introduce ambiguity; this is not a destructive or batch operation, so the workflow-clarity cap of 3 does not apply. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is well sectioned, and its references are real, one level deep, and clearly signaled ("Refer to [rob2_guidelines.md](references/rob2_guidelines.md)" and `scripts/assess_rob2.py` both exist in the bundle). Minor gaps keep it below anchor 5: `extract_pdf.py` is referenced without its `scripts/` path (inconsistent with `scripts/assess_rob2.py` styling), and its documented output filename contradicts the script's actual behavior, slightly confusing navigation to the right tool. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |