Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body has a clear structure, real one-level-deep references, and concrete output contracts (paths, CSV columns, template), but it is held back by generic template boilerplate occupying much of the document and by a comparison methodology that remains conceptual both in SKILL.md and in the thin guide.md it defers to. An unreferenced bundled checklist file is a minor organization gap.
Suggestions
Trim or merge the generic boilerplate sections (Required Inputs, Output Contract, Failure Handling, User Checkpoints, Input Validation, Quick Validation) into a few skill-specific lines — e.g., replace the Required Inputs table with the single real prerequisite: a PDF-to-Markdown full text with '## Page XX' markers and legend text.
Make the comparison step concrete: enumerate the specific checks to perform per figure (values, units, n-values, group names, time points, panel-level claims, missing figure references) either inline or with real detail in references/guide.md, instead of 'Compare legend statements against Results statements'.
Reference assets/figure_caption_checklist.csv from the body (e.g., in the workflow) so the bundled checklist is discoverable, and turn the generic Quick Validation section into concrete output checks (every CSV row uses 'Page XX', report follows the template, no-issue sections say 'None found').
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The skill-specific sections (When to Use, Example Usage, Implementation Details) are reasonably tight, but roughly 40% of the body is generic boilerplate ('Required Inputs' with rows like 'Primary input material | Depends on task | Text, file path, ID, table, or literature', 'Output Contract', 'Failure Handling', 'User Checkpoints', 'Input Validation', 'Quick Validation') that applies to any skill and adds tokens without skill-specific value. Not a 2 because the core instructions are not padded and no concepts Claude already knows are re-explained; not a 4 because the boilerplate sections are clearly trimmable. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | There is some concrete guidance: exact output paths ('outputs/consistency_report.md', 'outputs/consistency_issues.csv'), a literal CSV header ('Figure Number,Location/Reference,Issue Description,Suggested Revision,Priority'), the 'Page XX' location rule, and the 'None found' convention. But the core methodology is self-described as a 'Run (conceptual workflow)' — 'Compare legend statements against Results statements and record discrepancies' — with the actual checking rules deferred to references/guide.md, which itself only offers generic checks ('Consistency in values, units, and directions'). Not a 4 because the comparison step, the heart of the skill, lacks concrete executable detail. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear 4-step sequence is given (read input → identify result paragraphs and legend blocks → compare and record discrepancies → write the two named output files), with explicit checkpoints: the 'None found' no-issue case, a Failure Handling section ('Report the failing step, likely cause, and recovery suggestions — do not silently degrade'), PARTIAL marking for partial completion, and a Quick Validation section. Not a 5 because the validation checkpoints are generic boilerplate rather than concrete checks tied to this workflow (e.g., verifying each CSV row has a 'Page XX' location), and the workflow is labeled 'conceptual'. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is an overview that cleanly defers detail one level deep to real, verified files: 'references/guide.md' (exists) for checking rules and 'assets/consistency_template.md' (exists) for the report format, with paths stated inline at the point of need. Not a 5 because assets/figure_caption_checklist.csv is present in the bundle but never referenced from SKILL.md, leaving a bundled asset undiscoverable, and because the skill is simple enough that some inlined boilerplate sections dilute the overview. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |