Content
73%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An exceptionally actionable, well-validated orchestration protocol whose steps, commands, prompts and failure paths are copy-paste concrete. Its two weaknesses are structural: ~700 lines all inline in SKILL.md where the brief templates belong in separate reference files, and enough repeated restatement of the same rules that a tighter document could carry the same protocol in far fewer tokens.
Suggestions
Move the four brief templates (PLAN, DRAFT, REFINE, SELECT, FINALIZE) and their slot texts ({CONCLUDE_RULE}, {ESC_SUMMARY}, {ESC_WAVE}, {PARTIALS}, {PARTIALS_FIN}) into references/ files (e.g. references/plan-brief.md), leaving SKILL.md to state when each brief is launched and how its slots are filled.
State each rule once and reference it by name elsewhere — the ESC_ROUND worker-type and wave-cap rules are currently given in the approach section, in Settings, in Rules, and again inside the slot texts, and the 'do not copy the problem statement into query files' instruction appears in at least four places.
Break the 150-250-word legalistic run-on sentences (e.g. the four-paragraph Settings error-handling instruction and PLAN BRIEF item 2 (ii)) into shorter sentences or bullet lists; the content is procedural, not contractual, and would lose no precision.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The 733-line body contains no explanation of concepts Claude already knows — nearly every sentence is procedural — but the legalistic run-on style restates the same rules repeatedly (the ESC_ROUND worker-type and wave-cap rules appear in the approach section, in Settings, in Rules, and again inside the {ESC_SUMMARY}/{ESC_WAVE} slot texts). Fits anchor 3 ('mostly efficient but could be tightened'): the excess is redundancy, not explanation of known ground, so it stays above anchor 2. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable throughout: exact commands ("SCRIPT check DIR {r} {CAP} {MIN_ROUNDS} {attempt}"), a verbatim worker prompt template with the exact end line "=== END OF ANSWER {Q} ===", the fallback chain for locating ledger.py, prescribed actions for every verdict line (WAVE/CONCLUDE/RETRY/TAIL), and the literal grep command for the standalone check. Copy-paste ready with specific handling for the common and error cases — anchor 5. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The round loop (a)-(d) and proof tail (e)-(i) are explicitly sequenced with a mechanical validation layer throughout: the SCRIPT check verdicts, RETRY feedback loops, the SCRIPT answers finished/partial decision, the FLOOR stop rule, the SCRIPT gate short/full-tail decision, and the final grep standalone check with a repair pass. Explicit validation steps, feedback loops, and error recovery match anchor 5 exactly. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | A 733-line monolith: the PLAN BRIEF with its {CONCLUDE_RULE}/{HORIZON}/{ESC_SUMMARY}/{ESC_WAVE} slot texts alone runs roughly 300 lines, all inlined in SKILL.md, where these brief templates clearly belong in separate files loaded at need. The one external file (scripts/ledger.py) is clearly signaled, but there is no reference structure at all — fits anchor 2 ('content that clearly belongs in separate files is inlined'); not anchor 1 because section headers give real structure, not anchor 3 because the inline briefs go far beyond 'could be better organized'. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |